Who Was Voted Off American Idol? 2010-02-26 08:09:07

Which Eliminated Idol Contestant Will You Miss the Most?

February 26, 2010

Last night American Idol claimed its first four victims, giving the boot to Janell Wheeler, Ashley Rodriguez, Joe Munoz, and Tyler Grady. I wasn't surprised that Ashley and Tyler got the boot considering their so-so performances, but I think Janell and Joe may have deserved a second shot. Either way, I'm glad that some of the fat is trimmed and we can start getting into the heart of the competition. So tell me — which eliminated contestant will you miss the most?

Photo courtesy of Fox

TV American Idol American Idol Elimination Poll

16 Comments

3 years

Sorry ashley left liked her image think its always hard early evictions as takes time to show yourself properly i think loved the llrn track in background of result show

Harmonia 3 years

Tyler was one of the best for me, different, interesting, good voice, good looking, so I will definitely miss him, I thought Tim Urban or whatever his name is should have left..

zeze 3 years

so wait, there is no wildcard round this year? That would suck, I would have kept all four that went home over other people that stayed.

zeze 3 years

so wait, there is no wildcard round this year?That would suck, I would have kept all four that went home over other people that stayed.

3 years

joe monoz only left cuz the other guy was really cute- who sang apologize and had really nice eyes, but he sucked at singing. joe monuz should have stayed, it was so unfair!

3 years

Ashley is gorgeous but her voice isnt great.. Tyler is a joke. I agree with them going home But Janell was awesome and I love her voice, and Joe was actually pretty good. They shouldn't have gone home.

3 years

I'll miss Ashley, but only because of her clothes.

3 years

I agree, definitely the worst Idol. But Tyler was just so cute and I just loved his look. :)

animatedpunk 3 years

Yeah, I totally agree with anon. I thought those two girls were going to go as well. As for Tim Urban - at least he genuinely looked shocked - he knows he should have gone home.

animatedpunk 3 years

Yeah, I totally agree with anon. I thought those two girls were going to go as well.As for Tim Urban - at least he genuinely looked shocked - he knows he should have gone home.

lemuse20 3 years

Janell was the reason I decided I was going to watch this season.... bah :(

mommahello 3 years

I agree w/anon

mommahello 3 years

I agree w/anon

sarahcateh 3 years

Seriously, Joe was eliminated and Tim Urban wasn't??? What the hell America?

popcorn19 3 years

I loved Joe! He was one of the singers that the judges actually said had a great voice! And he was cute too!!

3 years

This has GOT to be the WORST idol yet. How are Janel and Ashley eliminated over the red head and the black cowgirl? They were both HORRENDOUS! And the apology guy stays! WTF?!

Link Love

16 Comments