Which Best Picture is Best? Play Our New Game!

February 20, 2008

Titanic and A Beautiful Mind both have Oscars for Best Picture to their credit — but imagine if they'd been made in the same year and had to face off against each other for the award. Which movie would have won? What about Crash vs. American Beauty? The Silence of the Lambs vs. Unforgiven?

As this year's Oscars draw near, we've loaded up all the Best Picture winners of the past 25 years and made them go head-to-head. Which movies do you think reign supreme? Start playing and see if you agree with what other folks are choosing.
Just click here to get started!

7 Comments

ovenmitt 5 years 13 weeks

so i thought about this a little and it makes sense that we're all doing poorly. it's based on what everyone else in the sugar intarwebs are saying. caterpillargirl is right - it really is about 20somethings and their votes. these kids aren't old enough to know how amazing tom hulce was; they don't remember f. murray abraham accepting the oscar for his role as salieri! btw, i didn't realize hulce and abraham were competing against one another! i'm glad to know he was nominated! he was incredible.

CaterpillarGirl 5 years 13 weeks

Are you serious? Crash is better than Amadeus? the "better" picture according to who? 20 somethings who have no idea what good movies are all about (and they arent about all star casts and anything made after 2000)