Which American Idol Contestant Is Going Home Next?

May 7, 2008

After tonight, we'll be down to three on American Idol! The top four took on songs from artists in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame on Tuesday night, striving for just the right balance between modern and classic. Who knocked it out of the park — and who was completely off-base? Make your prediction for who's going home now!

Photo courtesy of Fox

24 Comments

nikki_ 5 years 2 weeks

Jason should've gone weeks ago.. and this week he was horrible..

emalove 5 years 2 weeks

Jason has been terrible for weeks, he should go home for sure. But I have a feeling it will be Syesha.

buggyslice 5 years 2 weeks

It better be Jason! He should have gone home a long time ago.

LaLaLaurie06 5 years 2 weeks

if it's not Castro, I'm gonna be pissed!!!!!

Anabellatc 5 years 2 weeks

I used to like Jason but must agree with almost everyone here...it seems like he doesn't care anymore so I think he should go home. I also don't get the appeal of David A...he's kinda cute and a good singer but not fabulous or extremely talented in my opinion. He will prolly win because all the girls like him...i don't know...not impressed by any of the contestants this year!

megz0684 5 years 2 weeks

David cook better win it all... hes awesome and sexy i love him!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!lol Bye jason... time to go

aed15 5 years 2 weeks

i love jason, but after last night i'm not sure he'll stick around. his fan base is huge and could keep him there...but he seems like he's ready so leave. i think it should be syesha...she's very broadway and should pursue that. my money is on david cook to take it all.

rlindz 5 years 2 weeks

Jason is def. going to go. And I disagree that David Cook has it in the bag. I'm putting my money on Archuleta.

AliCherri1 5 years 2 weeks

Jason should have left WEEKS ago! Who the HACK is voting for this dude? I want David Cook or Sayesha to win b/c David bothers me.

Briandiesel 5 years 2 weeks

jay jay go bye bye

rickimc 5 years 2 weeks

Jason forgot his lyrics. It is the final four. Buh-bye!

yiddidea 5 years 2 weeks

Jason should go home. It seems like he doesn't really care if he is there anymore anyway. My favorite is David Cook but I actually don't want him to win. I would hate for him to have to make a watered down American Idol version of a rock album. Let David Archuletta win as he is PERFECT for the Idol formula. He is a great singer and appeals to the Idol fanbase.

duck duck goose 5 years 2 weeks

Castro, even with those darling blue eyes and sweet smile. But I still like him.

VThyne 5 years 2 weeks

You know, I used to like Jason, but I feel like it's the same thing every week. Time for him to go!

t and co 5 years 2 weeks

I really liked Jason, but his act is seriously getting old. Same with David A. I think David Cook has it in the bag, hands down.

jle225 5 years 2 weeks

Jason's definitely GOTTA go. He can't even be compared on the same level of the other three!!

Liss 5 years 2 weeks

Jason will probably go, but i hope it is Syesha. She bores me and i have to turn the channel when she is on. I just don't get the appeal of David A. I don't think he is good and I thought he butchered the Elvis song.

jennifer76 5 years 2 weeks

I really like Jason, but I just don't see how he stays after last night.

shernic82 5 years 2 weeks

I haven't watched the performances yet, so I won't vote until I do...but basing it on week to week, Jason has been due for a ticket home for about three weeks.

Link Love

24 Comments

You Might Also Like