Which American Idol Contestant is Going Home Next?

April 30, 2008

Good times never seemed so good? The top five American Idol contestants sang the songs of Neil Diamond on Tuesday — words that, frankly, I never thought I'd type. So, how did they do? And whose interpretation will land them a one-way ticket back home?

Photo courtesy of Fox

21 Comments

POPSUGAR Entertainment 5 years 3 weeks

Cara — I think you're thinking of Natasha Bedingfield

Cara607 5 years 3 weeks

What is the female singers name that performed elimination night? The girl that sang who after her performance, ran over and sat down by David A. and also asked David who he was taking to the Prom, she told him that she would go with him to the Prom... :) What is her name? I loved her song and want to download it....can someone please post her name and possibly the name of the song that she sang?? :)

californiagirlx7 5 years 3 weeks

I honestly don't know, it will probably be Syesha or Brooke.

duck duck goose 5 years 3 weeks

Jason or Brooke, though I'd prefer Sayesha or Archuleta get the cut tonight.

t and co 5 years 3 weeks

I think Brooke is on on the outs. She pratically has a nervous breakdown every week. I was hoping Simon would say something like, "It was a nightmare, Brooke. From the song choice, to your wardrobe, to the facial expressions..."

bealotus 5 years 3 weeks

who's David Castro? LOL :p Syesha needs to go home. And what's up with Paula? did she forget to take her pills or what!

SaRaH 22 5 years 3 weeks

David Castro drives me NUTSO!!! Please send him home!!

Yv 5 years 3 weeks

*with

Yv 5 years 3 weeks

i love David Cook. i actually started watching AI because of him. and i'm in Europe! [Poland to be exact] ;) his first solo album was average, but whith such a voice and music taste he's destined for greatness. i think Syesha is going home next, judging from last week results. after all it's popularity contest, not talent contest - unfortunately. for the same reason Jason Castro is still in the game. i do not see nothing here - he's cute and boring. Brooke has beautiful voice [and face (and can play the piano!)], but she's too country for me. David Archuleta - boysband material at best. and yeah, i agree with lily: Paula should definitely go home.

rlindz 5 years 3 weeks

Brooke really needs to go before anyone else. She is breaking down and losing it in front of America.

lily8206 5 years 3 weeks

Paula should go home. She needs to take a nap, rest her brain. Last night was hard, people!!!!

yiddidea 5 years 3 weeks

David Cook and Archuletta are definitely safe and I would bet Castro's rabid fans keep him in so it is probably between the two ladies. Honestly, Brooke's first song was a trainwreck (except for the end where she finally got it together) and Syesha still bores me.