Which American Idol Contestant Is Going Home Next?

April 16, 2008

Diva mentor Mariah Carey was in the Idol house last night, and the contestants worked hard to prove they too have what it takes to be record-setting stars. Carey — who certainly seems to be everywhere all of a sudden — has a vocal range wider than a football field and has sold millions of records, so no pressure at all on the top seven when they took on her catalog, I'm sure! Which singer do you think failed to rise to the challenge and will be headed home next?

Photo courtesy of Fox

20 Comments

aoitenshi 5 years 4 weeks

If Brooke goes before Kristy Lee and Syesha, I'm really going to stop watching Idol. :/

leeluvfashion 5 years 4 weeks

Syesha, however if she stays then I think Kristy will go home.

cha cha 5 years 4 weeks

KLC's staying power has amazed me. I was surprised at Carly's remarks about missing MJ soooo much. Just be happy YOU didn't get sent home. I know he's not the best singer but I voted for Jason 12 or 15 times.

JennaV 5 years 4 weeks

Kristy Lee Cook has gots to go

SofiaNYC 5 years 4 weeks

As long as David Archuleta & David Cook are safe i could care less who goes home.....however, what was America (WE!!!) thinking when we let MJ go home?? He was awesome!! Can we vote to bring him back? Maybe trade him for Kristy Lee Cook?

radarkitty 5 years 4 weeks

I hate both of the David's. Hate them. One reminds me of a troll and the other is a wussy.

Hootie 5 years 4 weeks

I hope Brooke goes.

brittanybe 5 years 4 weeks

I understand what you're saying, swwonder. Phasekitty, I think the boys had a huge advantage last night because no one was comparing their voices to Mariah Carey. Pretty much all the girls got told that their voice wasn't as strong as mariah's-- but the boys did not suffer from that comparison.

PinkTink707 5 years 4 weeks

Brooke was kinda bad yesterday...she missed a step towards the end of the song...I def. think it will be her, Syesha and Carly in the bottom 3... and that's ok by me - b/c David Cook needs to win! He is phenomenal! He made me like that song again (they played it so much on the radio I couldn't stand it anymore)

Phasekitty 5 years 4 weeks

The boys are outsinging the girls by far on this season. I love Brooke, but she hasn't been able to get it right for a few weeks now and she could be gone after tonight. Hers was easily the worst performance- she's a great singer she just doesn't have that power voice that most Idols have.

eruntale 5 years 4 weeks

Yeah, I don't like Kristy Lee Cook's singing style at all. It's awesome that she enjoys Country music so much but she wants to "countrify" everything and it's becoming boring. I love Brooke but she's not doing it right for some weeks now. Maybe she'll get the boot... what a pity, she's so beautiful and talented. And about Michael, he's soooo gorgeus! (but not as gorgeous as Dave Cook :) I'm sure he's going to be a great rockstar, Idol or not.

em1282 5 years 4 weeks

"Syesha and KLC should've gone home WEEKS ago (CERTAINLY before Michael) so I basically pretend they aren't there. It's easier for my sanity" Hee! Kristy Lee should go home. She sucked.

Renees3 5 years 4 weeks

I thought Brooke was pretty bad last night. I think she'll be in the bottom 3, but she has a decent following so might not go home. Carly wasn't very good either, which is a shame because she has a nice voice. I liked all the guys though. Syesha and KLC should've gone home WEEKS ago (CERTAINLY before Michael) so I basically pretend they aren't there. It's easier for my sanity

j2e1n9 5 years 4 weeks

I cant believe KLC is still there. I'm blown away :? They need to kick her off pronto, or else she'll be another one of the Idol losers who still gets an album and we still have to hear her crap and see her continuously!

swwonder 5 years 4 weeks

Eugh it bugs me so much that I can't vote (not that I vote for the UK one, but still). I really want Kristy Lee Cook or Syesha gone. I think very few this time around have the ability to be popular in places other than the US. Kristy Lee and Syesha are the ones I definitely don't find relevant in the UK, if that makes sense.