Vote on This Week's Project Runway Winner and Loser 2010-03-26 08:30:14

Do You Agree With This Week's Project Runway Winner and Loser?

March 26, 2010

Project Runway explored new territory this week, asking the contestants to design their own textile for their runway look. I appreciated the opportunity for the contestants to show their creativity, but some were completely flummoxed by producing and using a print.

The judges and guest Vivienne Tam gave the win to the dress I was the biggest fan of — but I didn't necessarily agree with the competitor they kicked off, compared with the other design in the bottom. What did you think?

Photos courtesy of Lifetime

22 Comments

Soniabonya 3 years 7 weeks

Just watched last night. Mila should have gone home. I'm tired of her color blocking one trick pony and her fabric design was completely uninspired. And her model couldn't even walk properly! Ugly and ill designed. Emilio shouldn't have won. He shouldn't even be there after the pink bikini disaster. His ego and narcissism has been annoying me and disliking him more and more.I was hoping for Maya to win. She worked her butt off for this and she can design! Her outfit and her model were fierce!I was completely revolted by the judges disgusting behavior against Johnathon's work. They were overly harsh on his piece and like blind fools could not see the beauty in it. And Korr's comments...ugh. Very low. I liked J's work and applaud him for sticking by it. Poor Cerri. I liked her and was disappointed in Johnathon for not sticking with her while she stuck up for him.

Soniabonya 3 years 7 weeks

Just watched last night. Mila should have gone home. I'm tired of her color blocking one trick pony and her fabric design was completely uninspired. And her model couldn't even walk properly! Ugly and ill designed. Emilio shouldn't have won. He shouldn't even be there after the pink bikini disaster. His ego and narcissism has been annoying me and disliking him more and more. I was hoping for Maya to win. She worked her butt off for this and she can design! Her outfit and her model were fierce! I was completely revolted by the judges disgusting behavior against Johnathon's work. They were overly harsh on his piece and like blind fools could not see the beauty in it. And Korr's comments...ugh. Very low. I liked J's work and applaud him for sticking by it. Poor Cerri. I liked her and was disappointed in Johnathon for not sticking with her while she stuck up for him.

esweet 3 years 7 weeks

Mila should have gone home, period. If she is not color-blocking she can't design. I LOVE Seth Aaron -- I actually wouldn't wear his punk-style, but he is super talented and creative. His clothes look impecable, no matter how long they have for the challenge. Love him.

zeze 3 years 7 weeks

I think they might be keeping Maya under the radar for a possible surprise winner? At least I hope.I HATED Mila's designs, all of them, including the ones they praise are horrible, weird fitting, and boring!I really liked Anthony's dress.And wtf is up with Michael Kors and everyone else laughing at the designer with the gray dress (forgot his name), I loved the dress but I do agree his jacket was out there, but we've seen worse on this show and his print was beautiful, classy and subtle...calling it a dirty table cloth showed a lack of creativity on the Kors's part. I've been to his boutique a few times and some of those clothes are terrible...so it's a bit harsh mock a designer who made a pretty cute dress.

zeze 3 years 7 weeks

I think they might be keeping Maya under the radar for a possible surprise winner? At least I hope. I HATED Mila's designs, all of them, including the ones they praise are horrible, weird fitting, and boring! I really liked Anthony's dress. And wtf is up with Michael Kors and everyone else laughing at the designer with the gray dress (forgot his name), I loved the dress but I do agree his jacket was out there, but we've seen worse on this show and his print was beautiful, classy and subtle...calling it a dirty table cloth showed a lack of creativity on the Kors's part. I've been to his boutique a few times and some of those clothes are terrible...so it's a bit harsh mock a designer who made a pretty cute dress.

postmodernsleaze 3 years 7 weeks

I love Seth Aaron too, pumachik, I wish he won this last challenge. His designs rock and they're so tailored. He's my favorite designer this season for sure. Personally, I think Emilio should have left after that hot pink bathing suit travesty in the Hard Wear episode. Mila's dress was a big giant disaster this episode and I wanted to cry when Anthony had to leave. But I do understand what the judges meant about all of Anthony's work looking the same.I'm also super sad that model Cerri had to leave, I loved her. I'm surprised Jonathan chose another model after Cerri defended his design. Pooey!

postmodernsleaze 3 years 7 weeks

I love Seth Aaron too, pumachik, I wish he won this last challenge. His designs rock and they're so tailored. He's my favorite designer this season for sure. Personally, I think Emilio should have left after that hot pink bathing suit travesty in the Hard Wear episode. Mila's dress was a big giant disaster this episode and I wanted to cry when Anthony had to leave. But I do understand what the judges meant about all of Anthony's work looking the same. I'm also super sad that model Cerri had to leave, I loved her. I'm surprised Jonathan chose another model after Cerri defended his design. Pooey!

fakeplanettelex 3 years 8 weeks

mila should have been kicked off. i DESPISE her. her print looked like someone drew crayons all over it. emilio should not have won. i was shocked. it should have been seth aaron or maya. seth aaron because he's my fave - but i think maya stepped it up for this one and went out of her element to prove she could do this.i'm rooting for seth aaron 110% of the way. he has vision, executes well, and can think the big picture. not to mention, all of his looks are fab. p.s. emilio only won last week because he was on seth aaron's team (sa's look was WAY better & captured the spirit they were going for). he should have been voted off a long time ago. whatever, judges.

fakeplanettelex 3 years 8 weeks

mila should have been kicked off. i DESPISE her. her print looked like someone drew crayons all over it. emilio should not have won. i was shocked. it should have been seth aaron or maya. seth aaron because he's my fave - but i think maya stepped it up for this one and went out of her element to prove she could do this. i'm rooting for seth aaron 110% of the way. he has vision, executes well, and can think the big picture. not to mention, all of his looks are fab. p.s. emilio only won last week because he was on seth aaron's team (sa's look was WAY better & captured the spirit they were going for). he should have been voted off a long time ago. whatever, judges.

a million suns 3 years 8 weeks

WHAT was with Emilio WINNING?! AGH! I liked the actual silhouette of the dress, but it wasn't exactly innovative, and I HATED the print. It didn't look like graffiti to me, it looked more like a kindergartner wrote some random letters with crayon. And don't even get me started on hearts--because HEARTS? Come on! It didn't appear that he put any thought into it whatsoever, and the fact that it's own initials just makes it clear that he's a narcissist (oh, and the hearts don't help with that either). He has certainly not achieved the level of success that would validate such a decision. Anthony is hilarious, but I don't think he deserved to stay this week based on his work. So at least I agree with the judges on SOMETHING.

a million suns 3 years 8 weeks

WHAT was with Emilio WINNING?! AGH! I liked the actual silhouette of the dress, but it wasn't exactly innovative, and I HATED the print. It didn't look like graffiti to me, it looked more like a kindergartner wrote some random letters with crayon. And don't even get me started on hearts--because HEARTS? Come on! It didn't appear that he put any thought into it whatsoever, and the fact that it's own initials just makes it clear that he's a narcissist (oh, and the hearts don't help with that either). He has certainly not achieved the level of success that would validate such a decision.Anthony is hilarious, but I don't think he deserved to stay this week based on his work. So at least I agree with the judges on SOMETHING.

bchicgrl 3 years 8 weeks

I completely agree on the whole Mila should have been booted, her dress was soo fricken ugly what was she thinking when she designed that print. While I agree Anthony has been repetitive with his designs I liked the pattern he created. As for Emilio, I liked the idea of a graffiti print since a lot of designers have something similar.

seven7 3 years 8 weeks

I don't even know how Emilio is still there after that hardware look fiasco, I liked both Maya and Seth Aaron's looks way better for this challenge. It's a pity Anthony was let go, but I kind of knew he would not last to bryant park. He's a great person, but I don't think a top contender. Still, considering Brandise couldn't even walk in the dress - poor girl - I would have sent Mila packing. I don't get the judges attachment to Mila, anyway. I don't think I've ever seen a contestant in the bottom 3 that many times in a row without getting kicked off.

seven7 3 years 8 weeks

Lavinie 3 years 8 weeks

i was upset to see that Anthony was kicked off... are you kidding me?! mila's dress was horrible... totally unwearable - and it wasn't even a pattern! and she gets to stay?!anthony made a perfectly wearable dress - stylish and cute... i was really upset with their decision.. grr.

Lavinie 3 years 8 weeks

i was upset to see that Anthony was kicked off... are you kidding me?! mila's dress was horrible... totally unwearable - and it wasn't even a pattern! and she gets to stay?! anthony made a perfectly wearable dress - stylish and cute... i was really upset with their decision.. grr.

3 years 8 weeks

Tim Gunn's blog says it all. I agree with him 100%.

3 years 8 weeks

Emilio is arrogant, he's a great designer but arrogant, and his print was not all that. Maia should have won, and Mila should have been kicked off. I'm getting a strange feeling that Emilio may win this thing much to my chagrin much like last year's winner. Apparently being full of yourself is the way to go if you wanna win.

kismekate 3 years 8 weeks

Should have been the opposite way around!!!

lilkimbo 3 years 8 weeks

I too think they made the wrong decisions all around. I think Maya should have won and Mila should have been kicked off. Then again, I haven't agreed with a lot of their choices this season.

3 years 8 weeks

Terrible decision - Anthony got robbed. Mila should have gotten kicked off - dress was not wearable. Project Runway lost me as a viewer!!! Shame on the judges. Anthony, if you are reading this - your dress was something I WOULD wear!!! ALl the best to you.

littlekaren 3 years 8 weeks

I screamed. I couldn't believe it. Not ONLY that [that person] got kicked off, but that the judges LIKED a couple of those HIDEOUS print designs. COME ON. Really?!?!?! WTF! I was with Tim Gunn on this one. That "graffiti" pattern? No way in HELL I would EVER even THINK of buying something that hideous in a million years. And it freakin WON! I like Maya. She is UNDER-APPRECIATED by those judges! UGH! I'm really hacked off about it all.

Link Love

22 Comments

You Might Also Like