Vote on This Week's Project Runway Winner and Loser 2010-03-19 07:30:30

Do You Agree With This Week's Project Runway Winner and Loser?

March 19, 2010

Project Runway gave the designers one of my favorite challenges ever: use inspiration from a New York City neighborhood. Even though I normally dislike team challenges, the pairings and results made for a super interesting episode.

With guests Francisco Costa and Molly Sims, the judges awarded what I thought were the best looks, but they eliminated one of my favorite designers. I'm bummed, but my heart will go on. What did you think of the outcome?

Photos courtesy of Lifetime

4 Comments

lilkimbo 3 years 7 weeks

Lizlee, first of all, even though it's probably not necessarily true, the judges claim that they make their decisions (other than the last decision) based on that design, not the season as a whole. Secondly, I think Amy's designs were better than Jay's. I actually thought Amy's hardware store/sand paper dress was spectacular and was shocked that it wasn't even in the top three. Additionally, I didn't think her pants for the children/mom's challenge were downright awful. I thought they were interesting and creative. I really think her only bad design was the one with the fire/hair idea. This week's wasn't right for Cerri, but it wasn't horrible. I really liked the colors and the pleating, actually.While I actually like Jay's personality just as much as Amy's, I think his design has been on par with, or maybe slightly worse than hers. I didn't like his red dress at all, I think his Marie Claire cover look totally missed the mark, and, even though the judges loved it, I really didn't like his hardware store look.I guess that's the thing with fashion/style. It's all subjective!Also, I actually like

lilkimbo 3 years 7 weeks

Lizlee, first of all, even though it's probably not necessarily true, the judges claim that they make their decisions (other than the last decision) based on that design, not the season as a whole. Secondly, I think Amy's designs were better than Jay's. I actually thought Amy's hardware store/sand paper dress was spectacular and was shocked that it wasn't even in the top three. Additionally, I didn't think her pants for the children/mom's challenge were downright awful. I thought they were interesting and creative. I really think her only bad design was the one with the fire/hair idea. This week's wasn't right for Cerri, but it wasn't horrible. I really liked the colors and the pleating, actually. While I actually like Jay's personality just as much as Amy's, I think his design has been on par with, or maybe slightly worse than hers. I didn't like his red dress at all, I think his Marie Claire cover look totally missed the mark, and, even though the judges loved it, I really didn't like his hardware store look. I guess that's the thing with fashion/style. It's all subjective! Also, I actually like

lizlee89 3 years 8 weeks

I know it's hard to separate emotions and likes/dislikes, but you have to look at whose designs as a whole have been better - even though I loved Amy and I don't really care eigther way for Jay (sometimes I really like him; sometimes he's kind of an annoying little bitch), Jay's designs have been better than Amy's. The truth is that, other than her potato sack dress (which was amazing and should have won that week) and her red dress (which was okay; beautiful but nothing new), none of her designs were spectacular and three were downright awful (the last two - well, last week's wasn't awful but the hair was - and the children/mom's challenge). I definitely thought Seth Aaron should have won (and should win the whole thing in the end) and Emilio should have been second (even though I hate him)...

lilkimbo 3 years 8 weeks

I agree with the top two teams and the bottom two teams, but I think Maya and Anthony should have won and Jay should have gone home.

Link Love

4 Comments

You Might Also Like