by POPSUGAR Entertainment 16

In a night filled with quite a few repeats, the Supernatural Christmas episode seems like it could be a bright spot. The episode finds brother demon-hunters Sam and Dean Winchester investigating a series of mysterious murders in which the victims were sucked up through the chimney — kind of like Santa in reverse. In fact, the brothers realize their killer himself is a demonic Anti-Santa.

Meanwhile, the episode also has a healthy dose of brotherly love, with flashbacks to the brothers' Christmases as kids. Does that mean we get to see more Jeffrey Dean Morgan as papa Winchester? I hope so!

To be honest, I haven't seen much Supernatural — but with how much I've been enjoying Reaper, maybe it's time for me to give it a shot. To check out a preview for tonight's episode, just read more.

Photo courtesy of The CW