Siobhan Magnus Voted Off American Idol

Was the Right Contestant Voted Off American Idol?

April 29, 2010

Though Siobhan Magnus gave her best performance in weeks during her Shania Twain performance on Tuesday night, she was eliminated from the competition this week. I have to admit I was a little shocked by the decision, especially since the judges gave her pretty decent feedback. The competition is really heating up now, with only five contestants remaining. So, what's your take — was Siobhan's time up?

Photo courtesy of Fox

14 Comments

cheechee524 3 years 3 weeks

I like Shioban, but she has definately been getting more boring lately. I think she is best with some personality, and I haven't seen any for weeks. I think she would be great as a frontperson for a band, but I really cant see her as a solo artist.

cheechee524 3 years 3 weeks

animatedpunk 3 years 3 weeks

I haven't LOVED her performances lately, but she definitely should have lasted longer than some others...... I just want to know..... HOW IS AARON STILL IN THIS??? I've ready for him to leave for weeks.

care0531 3 years 3 weeks

America DEFINETLY got it right! She signs all her songs slow and a bit pitchy and then goes into that scream. Last season Lambert screamed but he could sing in between too and she couldn't. I think Aaron will go next. This was his week... his theme. Casey sounded good for the first time this week...and Kara was right...he seems to hide behind the guitar where Crystal and Lee can sign and play the guitar.

care0531 3 years 3 weeks

America DEFINETLY got it right! She signs all her songs slow and a bit pitchy and then goes into that scream. Last season Lambert screamed but he could sing in between too and she couldn't.I think Aaron will go next. This was his week... his theme. Casey sounded good for the first time this week...and Kara was right...he seems to hide behind the guitar where Crystal and Lee can sign and play the guitar.

Daisy Duke 3 years 3 weeks

Thank goodness. It was definitely her time to go. So over her screaming. Send her to Broadway and get her out of our TV's every week!

mksmogger 3 years 3 weeks

I can't believe that Siobhan is gone - I guess the myth about country week taking out one of the biggest competitors each season has some truth to it. With only 5 people left, it's harder to say who should go next - I don't think it should be Casey even though America seems to be implying that. I'm gonna go out on a limb here...but Michael or Aaron? What do you think? http://thesmogger.com/2010/04/29/idol-hangover-the-final-five

doogirl 3 years 3 weeks

America totally got it wrong! Michael needs to go home, he's been skating on his personality this whole time. Crystal is going to win because she's awesome! I used to think that Lee was a throw away contestant but he's turning out to be pretty good. Aaron can go, his cutey 16 year old-ness is getting old.

3 years 3 weeks

So happy she is out! I could not stand to see her one more time on AI. The title will definitely be between Crystal and Lee. My favorite is Lee and I really hope he goes all the way...But if not he would still have a nice career in front of him. :)

lilkimbo 3 years 3 weeks

Coach, I think America got it right, so I guess it's not as clear as you seem to think it is. Siobhan started out OK, but she slipped a little each week. I actually thought she was pretty bad this week (her pitch was all over the place). I was shocked when the judges liked her this week.And I would definitely enjoy Crystal in concert. Siobhan, not so much. Additionally, I don't think Crystal has it in the bad. Lee is getting stronger and stronger each week.

lilkimbo 3 years 3 weeks

Coach, I think America got it right, so I guess it's not as clear as you seem to think it is. Siobhan started out OK, but she slipped a little each week. I actually thought she was pretty bad this week (her pitch was all over the place). I was shocked when the judges liked her this week. And I would definitely enjoy Crystal in concert. Siobhan, not so much. Additionally, I don't think Crystal has it in the bad. Lee is getting stronger and stronger each week.

coachalb 3 years 3 weeks

Clearly America got it wrong!!! The only really threat to the judge proclaimed winner Crystal (who sings only folk songs) is eliminated. Mike was easily the worse singer. Siobhan had the only voice and charisma that I could see buying. Can you see Crystal in a concert, would you pay for that? AI is fixed. The contest is over>

coachalb 3 years 3 weeks

LaurenG22 3 years 3 weeks

Once vftw got a hold of her, Americans realized she did suck. Her voice is nice but she really over pronounces everything she sings. I could see her in musical theater in Reno or Branson.

Link Love

14 Comments

You Might Also Like