Was the Right Contestant Voted Off American Idol?

Aaand we're down to 10! The bottom three of this week's American Idol had two contestants who also appeared in last week's: Tim and Paige. Katie joined them, but only briefly, and in the end, it was Paige who got the hook — without even getting a chance to be saved.

I was hardly shocked, as the judges had called it terrible. Do you think America kicked off the right person?

Photo courtesy of Fox

Latest