Was the Right Contestant Voted Off American Idol?

March 17, 2010

Now that American Idol is down to the top 12, there's only one contestant getting the boot each week. The bottom three — Lacey, Paige, and Tim — wasn't a big shocker, but I do think that Tim's looks may have helped him squeak by this week. In the end, Lacey was the first casualty of the single-elimination round. Do you think the right contestant was voted off?

Photo courtesy of Fox

8 Comments

3 years

I think Tim should have gone first than poor Lacey btw I loveeee Shioban awesomeness to the max!! :)

Hockey Princess 3 years

Does it even matter? The lack of talent this season is just stunning. Alex Lambert was the only one with a gift. Big Mike is a pretender. Crystal sounds exactly the same every week. And Shioban (sp?) is a lovely novelty act but nothing more. There is no growth potential in any remaining AI singers.

zeze 3 years

I think so, Paige has a great voice, though she hasn't really shown it yet. And I'm just not a fan of Lacey's voice at all, it kinda bugs me, so even at her best I don't like it. Tim is getting by because of his looks, he looks like Zac Efron.

zeze 3 years