Every other Wednesday on BuzzSugar, I post a Recast challenge, where I ask you to choose new actors for a classic TV show or movie. The reader who submits the best cast wins a BuzzSugar T-shirt!
I bet you guessed I would get around to this '80s television staple one of these days. This week, the time is right to recast Charles in Charge!
Normally, this is the part of the post where I remind you what the show was about, why it was memorable, etc. But thankfully, the theme song writers did that job for me via these classic lyrics:
New boy in the neighborhood/Lives downstairs and it is understood/He’s there just to take good care of me/Like he’s one of the family/Charles in Charge/Of our days and our nights/Charles in Charge/Of our wrongs and our rights
So basically he's part of the family, but he's a nanny, but the crazy thing is he's — wait for it — a guy!
What young, Scott Baio-esque hunk would you cast as Charles? Who could play his best buddy, er, Buddy? And what about the Powell kids? Who would play Jamie (originally played by ex-Baywatcher Nicole Eggert), Sarah, and Adam? Finally, let's recast Mrs. Powell, Walter Powell, and Charles's mom, Lillian.
Leave your entry in the comment section below, and I'll pick one winner to feature Tuesday, Sept. 2, complete with a "new" cast photo.
To see a list of characters to recast and a photo of the BuzzSugar T-shirt, read more.
Characters to recast
Charles (Scott Baio)
Mr. Walter Powell (James T. Callahan)
Mrs. Ellen Powell (Sandra Kerns)
Jamie Powell (Nicole Eggert)
Sarah Powell (Josie Davis)
Adam Powell (Alexander Polinsky)
Lillian (Ellen Travolta)
Buddy Lembeck (Willie Aames)
The BuzzSugar T-shirt




















Topman
I don't know about the rest of the cast, but I think that I would have Ashton Kutcher play Charles. He could punk the crap out of those little brats!
1Charles - John Cho
2Mr. Walter Powell - James Eckhouse
Mrs. Ellen Powell - Debra Messing
Jamie Powell - Emma Stone
Sarah Powell - Emma Roberts
Adam Powell - Alexander Gould
Lillian - Catherine Hicks
Buddy Lembeck - Kal Penn
Charles (Scott Baio)- Shia LaBeouf
3Mr. Walter Powell (James T. Callahan)- George Clooney
Mrs. Ellen Powell (Sandra Kerns)- Nicole Kidman
Jamie Powell (Nicole Eggert)- Taylor Momsen
Sarah Powell (Josie Davis)- Dakota Fanning
Adam Powell (Alexander Polinsky)- Jimmy Bennett
Lillian (Ellen Travolta)- Brooke Shields
Buddy Lembeck (Willie Aames)- Michael Cera
Charles - Jake Gyllenhaal
4Mr. Walter Powell - Terry O'Quinn
Mrs. Ellen Powell - Kelly Rutherford
Jamie Powell - Blake Lively
Sarah Powell - Ashley Tisdale
Adam Powell - Alexander Gould
Lillian - Frances McDormand
Buddy Lembeck - Ashton Kutcher
Charles - Penn Badgley
5Mr. Walter Powell - James Caan
Mrs. Ellen Powell - Kelly Rutherford
Jamie Powell - Amber Heard
Sarah Powell - AnnaSophia Robb
Adam Powell - Cole Sprouse
Lillian - Wendie Malick
Buddy Lembeck - Robert Hoffman
Politico Version
Charles: Barack Obama
6Mr. Walter Powell: Arnold Schwarzenegger
Mrs. Ellen Powell: Nancy Pelosi
Jamie Powell: Chelsea Clinton
Sarah Powell: Jenna Bush
Adam Powell: Jack Edwards
Lillian: Hilary Clinton
Buddy Lembeck: Joe Biden
Charles (Scott Baio) -- Adam Brody
7Mr. Walter Powell (James T. Callahan) -- William H. Macy
Mrs. Ellen Powell (Sandra Kerns) -- Felicity Huffman
Jamie Powell (Nicole Eggert) -- Ellen Page
Sarah Powell (Josie Davis) -- Emily Osment (from Hannah Montana)
Adam Powell (Alexander Polinsky) -- Lorenzo Brino (one of the twins from 7th Heaven)
Lillian (Ellen Travolta) -- Catherine Keener
Buddy Lembeck (Willie Aames) -- Simon Helberg (Big Bang Theory)
Boy, I used to totally ADORE Charles in Charge! Back in it's time it was THE show to watch, I remember skipping school for it! LOL
8Anyway, as for the recasting:
Charles - Paul Rudd
9Mr. Walter Powell - Steve Martin
Mrs. Ellen Powell - Helen Hunt
Jamie Powell - Isla Fischer
Sarah Powell - Kristen Stewart
Adam Powell - Alexander Gould
Lillian - Diane Keaton (or perhaps Ellen Degeneres)
Buddy Lembeck - Sean William Scott
Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.