Penn Badgley in What I Like About You Video

by POPSUGAR Entertainment 4

Penn Badgley plays a money-hungry Wall Street financial analyst in this week's Margin Call, but back in the early 2000s he played a teenager who worked at a copy store alongside Amanda Bynes's character Holly in What I Like About You. While not making copies, he tried to get in good with Holly, bringing her lattes and jumping at the chance to help her replace the toner — that is, until Holly lets him know she just wants to be friends. Watch as he tries to convince Holly that he never liked her and handles his rejection poorly, poking fun at Holly for thinking he had a thing for her and even calling himself a "stone cold player."