Karen Rodriguez Voted Off American Idol

Was the Right Contestant Voted Off American Idol?

by 2

It was a night of few surprises on this week's American Idol elimination episode. Once again, the bottom three spots were filled by the ladies, with Naima joining Karen and Haley, who were on the chopping block last week. Haley and Naima were spared, while Karen gave it one last chance with Mariah Carey's "Hero." Personally I think Karen was better than Haley this week, but it was Karen who went home at the end of the night. Do you think America made the right decision?

Photo courtesy of Fox

TVAmerican IdolAmerican Idol Elimination Poll

2 Comments

Karen made a hughe mistake. She should have never said "it's time for a Latina idol." The other mistake was singing part of her song in Spanish. The third mistake was showing her mom commenting on her in a thick spanish accent. Karen doesn't watch the new much - if she did, she would have known about the anti-hispanic climate in America. It doesn't bother me at all that she is a Latina and song part of a song in Spanish. Karen's a beautiful young woman with an amazing voice. Ameerican Idol was not the venue for her. Same with the three (now two) African-Americans. They have absolutely no chance of making the top 5 let along winning it.
There is NO WAY she should have gone home before Haley!
NBC Thursday Night Comedy Block Review of Parks and Recreation, 30 Rock, Community, and More
Which NBC Comedy Owned Thursday Night This Week?
American Reunion Casts Jason Biggs, Sean William Scott, and Eugene Levy to Reprise Roles 2011-03-16 17:29:47
The American Pie Reunion Starts Lining Up Its Cast — Who Else Should Sign On?