Charlize Theron [1] and Josh Hartnett [2] joined Jimmy Fallon [3] and announcer Steve Higgins for a game of charades on Tuesday's episode of The Tonight Show. Charlize, who is promoting the Western comedy A Million Ways to Die in the West, tried to throw off her competition by acting confused at first — "I answer? I grab this?" — and Josh, who is currently starring in the Showtime series Penny Dreadful, was just as hot as we expected he would be [4] while also being way too excited to guess teammate Jimmy's clues. Watch Charlize and Josh face off against each other on The Tonight Show below.