All
  • All
  • Products
  • Articles
  • Videos
  • Galleries
  • Conversations
  • Social

Jacob Lusk Voted Off American Idol

Was the Right Contestant Voted Off American Idol?

by 16

With only five contestants left, we're getting down to the wire on American Idol. This week Jacob and Lauren landed in the bottom two, and Lauren's tears started flowing almost immediately after they got the bad news. Luckily, she had a reason to dry her eyes just 10 minutes later when Jacob's name was called for elimination. It seemed like his number was up after his first song on Tuesday night; the judges weren't generous with their usual praise, and it just wasn't his best. What are your thoughts — was the right contestant voted off American Idol?

Photo courtesy of Fox

American IdolBuzz Poll

16 Comments

cibele cibele
I don't understand Scotty's appeal either. He seems uni dimensional in his singing. I'm rooting for Haley, unique pretty voice. But I don't think she's going to win or get in the Top2.
cibele cibele
I don't understand Scotty's appeal either. He seems uni dimensional in his singing. I'm rooting for Haley, unique pretty voice. But I don't think she's going to win or get in the Top2.
care0531 care0531
I thought he was going to go 2 or 3 weeks ago! Hayley has been making a comback the last couple weeks. She is so good sometimes and other times I find her voice a little annoying. Not sure what it is. For some reason I think Scotty gets a lot of votes! Dial Idol always has him as recieving the most votes and he has been listed in the top spot every week except for 1 week! I don't get it! Lauren I have loved since her audition! I felt bad for her being in the bottom 2 but she did hold back that high note in her second song I even noticed that! Then James....I think he is good but I think he is too similar to other contastants in the past. I think he might win it all because people love his story. I found myself loving this season and feeling it was so talented at the beginning and now I feel as if I am not blown away by anyone every single week. :(
care0531 care0531
I thought he was going to go 2 or 3 weeks ago!Hayley has been making a comback the last couple weeks. She is so good sometimes and other times I find her voice a little annoying. Not sure what it is.For some reason I think Scotty gets a lot of votes! Dial Idol always has him as recieving the most votes and he has been listed in the top spot every week except for 1 week! I don't get it!Lauren I have loved since her audition! I felt bad for her being in the bottom 2 but she did hold back that high note in her second song I even noticed that!Then James....I think he is good but I think he is too similar to other contastants in the past. I think he might win it all because people love his story.I found myself loving this season and feeling it was so talented at the beginning and now I feel as if I am not blown away by anyone every single week. :(
Shannon Vestal Shannon Vestal
Yes.
Shannon Vestal Shannon Vestal
Yes.
Burkina Burkina
Haley can't sing. The Glambert wannabe is overrated. But America isn't ready for gospel.
I'm so bummed that Casey was booted off. He was THE BEST! If he ever comes to Hawaii I am going to his concert!
^Ha thats hilarious. Thank you! HA!
He sould have been votes off long ago! Like #25!!
Gdeeaz Gdeeaz
Wow anonymous calling me an idiot is really uncalled for. Someone has anger issues. The result was posted on the main page of the entertainment section so there was no need to click on the story to see the results. I didn't think I had to worry about buzz posting spoilers since they are usually good about keeping results off the main page.
Gdeeaz Gdeeaz
Wow anonymous calling me an idiot is really uncalled for. Someone has anger issues. The result was posted on the main page of the entertainment section so there was no need to click on the story to see the results. I didn't think I had to worry about buzz posting spoilers since they are usually good about keeping results off the main page.
They are all so good, but I would have went with Lauren to have left. Jacob has a amazing voice. Glad I could not watch to night since I read that Lady Gaga was singing Judas tonight. TV would have been turned off immediately and I may boycot Idol because of this.
He has been way overdue. Much more talented and entertaining people went before he did. Should have been both of them.
Yes it was his time to go and weirdo scotty is next! My prediction is Hailey! She got that awesome uniqueness to her, you dont hear too many voices out there like hers!
Gdeeaz Gdeeaz
American Idol hasn't aired on the west coast. This totally spoiled it for me.
Something Blue Movie Poll
Does Something Borrowed Deserve a Film Sequel?
May TV Season Finales
Which May TV Finale Are You Most Excited For?