Sometimes it's hard to believe that Michael Emerson doesn't even appear in the first season of Lost, because at this point Ben pretty much defines the show. He is by far one of the most complex villains I've ever met, after all these years, making Emerson's performances a joy to watch. He's gone home empty-handed in the past, but still an Emmy force to be reckoned with. Chance of winning: High
Photo copyright 2009 ABC, Inc.