Do You Agree With This Week's Project Runway Winner and Loser?

October 16, 2009

This week's Project Runway brought on a legendary stage costume designer who loves to use sequins and glitz (Bob Mackie) and a star who loves to wear them (Christina Aguilera). It also marked the triumphant return of Nina Garcia on the judging panel, who's been mostly absent this season. Her judging and critique are such a comfort to hear (and I would have paid Tim Gunn to tell someone "Don't bore Nina!").

The winner is someone I felt was particularly deserving this round, and the loser is someone I was a little surprised to see go. What did you think of the judging?

(Note: the pictured outfits are not necessarily the winning and losing looks).

Photos courtesy of Lifetime

17 Comments

zeze 3 years 30 weeks

I was shocked to see shirin go home, especially after I saw what I thought was a spoiler on Buzz. Christophers was horrible, I can make a better corset and I can't sew! And the pants looked like a diaper. I agree with the winner, because Nicholas' had been done before over and over again. Irena is a B*tch, I love how she is always wrong too, a few times the person she has mocked is the winner (I'm sure they edit it that way and in reality she mocks everyone) if she is go great why does she need a reality show to get anywhere? And I am so glad Nina is back, she said exactly what I am thinking, that basically this group is not that great...all their looks have been done before.

zeze 3 years 30 weeks

I was shocked to see shirin go home, especially after I saw what I thought was a spoiler on Buzz. Christophers was horrible, I can make a better corset and I can't sew! And the pants looked like a diaper. I agree with the winner, because Nicholas' had been done before over and over again.Irena is a B*tch, I love how she is always wrong too, a few times the person she has mocked is the winner (I'm sure they edit it that way and in reality she mocks everyone) if she is go great why does she need a reality show to get anywhere?And I am so glad Nina is back, she said exactly what I am thinking, that basically this group is not that great...all their looks have been done before.

Fellora 3 years 30 weeks

Christopher should have gone home. I liked him at the beginning, but lately he sucks. I was shocked when they sent Shirin home. Yay Carol Hannah won!

californiagirlx7 3 years 30 weeks

I'm glad that Carol Hannah won, the dress seemed like it was definitely something that Christina would wear or Bob Mackie would design. I also really liked Althea's look too. Gordana should've gone home instead of Shirin, but of course she saved because she had immunity.

californiagirlx7 3 years 30 weeks

I'm glad that Carol Hannah won, the dress seemed like it was definitely something that Christina would wear or Bob Mackie would design. I also really liked Althea's look too.Gordana should've gone home instead of Shirin, but of course she saved because she had immunity.

Nadia24gv 3 years 30 weeks

I love Christopher but really...he should have gone last night. And he doesn't go next week either because Katie said something in the preview that let's you know he is still there. Logan's was the WORST! wth was that? Poor guy. I think Nicolas should have won but they obviously just wanted to give it to Carol Hannah. You can always pick the winner within the first 10 minutes of the show if you pay attention to what they say.

bchicgrl 3 years 30 weeks

While I loved Carol Hannah's look, I don't think she should have won that challenge. I think Irina's, Althea's, and Nicolas's looks were a little better. As for Shirin going home, what a joke it should have been Christopher. He is constantly in the bottom and this is only Shirin's first slip up.

Soniabonya 3 years 30 weeks

I agree with the winner. Was rooting for her to finally get a win :) But I had to disagree with sending Shirin home. Christopher has been on the chopping block at least two or three times before this. Too many chances I say. My fiance and I were both shocked that the sent Shirin home. And Gordana was lucky she had immunity because that outfit was trash!

Soniabonya 3 years 30 weeks

billyart101 3 years 30 weeks

i Adoooooooored last night's episode. It was so gratifying to see my girl up there. I agree with the winner. It's so something Christina would wear (has worn--2006 Fashion Rocks red carpet), but the loser I didn't agree with...I think Christina just liked Christopher's sweet and earnest disposition.

3 years 30 weeks

Carol Hannah deserved to win and even though im tired of Shirin's whining, i didn't think she deserved to go home, nor did Epperson when he bit the bullet...Nicolas' bride dress was a hot mess and yet he stayed, i guess they keep the controversial ones on for good TV but in the end, they already know who's going to win...i hope its gordana

leslievanhouten 3 years 30 weeks

Don't let the spoiler cry babies win!That said, I loved that Carol Hannah won, though Nicholas' dress had better construction, it looked like it had been done before.Christopher's was horrible, actually Gordana's was worse, but she had immunity. I was sad to see Shirin go, because Christopher's look was worse

leslievanhouten 3 years 30 weeks

Don't let the spoiler cry babies win! That said, I loved that Carol Hannah won, though Nicholas' dress had better construction, it looked like it had been done before. Christopher's was horrible, actually Gordana's was worse, but she had immunity. I was sad to see Shirin go, because Christopher's look was worse

FireFly44 3 years 30 weeks

I am so glad Carol Hannah finally won! I think most of what she does is so beautiful but they always praise Althea's hot messes instead. I also really loved Nikolas's dress, it was VERY Bob Mackie-esque. I thought Shirin was too talented to go home over one bad outfit. Christopher and Logan did way worse but for some reason keep sticking around. (for tv I'm sure) Why does Buzz keep posting the incorrect winning/losing outfits? That was not Shirin's dress. And last week Carol's dress was shown instead of Gordana's.

FireFly44 3 years 30 weeks

demarco11 3 years 30 weeks

This is full of spoilers, but why you'd read this if you havent watched already is puzzling to me!I really thought Christopher was going home. The judges have hated some of his looks, but he still survives. Sad to see Shirin go! she really lost herself in this challenge, but i would have liked to see her stay. I thought Logan's was the weakest and I dont know why he keeps getting by week to week, still cant remember seeing anything impressive by him. Glad Carol Hannah won!

demarco11 3 years 30 weeks

This is full of spoilers, but why you'd read this if you havent watched already is puzzling to me! I really thought Christopher was going home. The judges have hated some of his looks, but he still survives. Sad to see Shirin go! she really lost herself in this challenge, but i would have liked to see her stay. I thought Logan's was the weakest and I dont know why he keeps getting by week to week, still cant remember seeing anything impressive by him. Glad Carol Hannah won!

Link Love

17 Comments

You Might Also Like