Do You Agree With This Week's Winner and Loser on Project Runway?

September 18, 2009

Eva Longoria and Tommy Hilfger took their runway-side seats to judge this week's episode of Project Runway. The designers took on one of their toughest challenges yet, as they crafted beautiful garments made only from newspaper. I was impressed with everyone this week, though the challenge loser was pretty obvious. What about you — do you agree with who was in and who was out?

Photos courtesy of Lifetime

17 Comments

clareberrys 3 years

im really happy johnny went home -its about time! Christopher's dress was AMAZING and it definitely should have won this time! I agree it was nice to see something other than dresses, but I just didnt like the coat that Irina made - I thought it was kind of ugly. I liked Altheas dress better too and better than the one she made last week that she won with (which I did not think she should have won that competition!)

danidaniramirez 3 years

totally agree!... the only thing about project runway that gets boring is that they alway do dresses. so it was nice to see something different like a jacket.. and it looks amazing to be made of paper

lizlee89 3 years

I thought Althea should have won this week instead of last week (not that I didn't like hers last week but this week's hers was by far the best of the group). I agree that Johnny should have gone home because of his attitude and the fact that his moderate talent was not on par with all the other designers'; but I actually thought his dress was amazing. It's hard to judge though because I think the problem was the construction (which you can't really see it detail on tv; the judges were probably able to see it a lot better) and I also think the whole drama with the lie had to do with their decision. but I loved Johnny's dress - the print was fantastic! I also think that Louise should have been in the bottom three rather than Gordana - her dress was awful. I'm satisfied though...

jhilly123 3 years

Agree with the loser, but I liked Christopher and Althea's dresses better too.

EML13 3 years

I'm glad Johnny went home, but I thought Christopher's dress was sure to win.

ecel4687 3 years

honestly I was suprised Irina was in the top 3--I thought her coat looked like a bathrobe!

Happsmjc 3 years

i completely agree with what others said--agree with the loser--but althea should have won :)

tellmemorex2 3 years

I wish Christopher won..but I agree with Johnny leaving..Nicolas should have gone too.

shmoo15 3 years

I thought Althea's dress should have won.

littlekaren 3 years

I wish that BOTH the bottom two would have been booted. And the winner... eh. It would have impressed much more if she'd given any time to coloring/treating the surface... not just leaving it newsprint. The others showed what can really be done so that your piece doesn't even look like paper anymore! (btw, I think Althea is the break-out design star in this whole thing.)

3 years

I personally thought based on looks alone that Nicolas should have gone home. They couldn't find anything positive to say about his work, and they did find a few redeeming qualities about Johnny's. I think his fibbing is what got him in trouble. But I'm thinking Nicolas is the next to go. I can't STAND him! As much as I loved the trench coat, I think Christopher's should have one. It was obviously the one that took the most work and it was impecable. Even Tommy Hilfiger said the back of the trench was sloppy. P.S. When the hell are Michael and Nina coming back to the judges panel?! MK is half the reason I watch!

kimretta 3 years

Gordana being in the bottom really surprised me, but I bet a lot of people were clustered close together and one of them had to be in the bottom. Hers was miles above the actual bottom two (and I wish they both could have gone home!)

3 years

Also, I liked Logan's and Carol Hannah's designs better than the one Irina showed. And Louise's was awful.

zeze 3 years

I agreed with the losser, Jordana did not deserve to be bottom three, what about Emerson's kimono mess?! So happy to see the insect dress down there as well after all his blabbing. The winner - I'm ok with, the Chris's dress was really nice as well, but I did loveee the trench coat! And I love how whenever Irena and Alfia insult each other's designs that one who got insulted wins. This group is a lot more catty and sadly, i love it.

3 years

I liked both Christopher's and Althea's better.

juliamurray 3 years

i agree with the loser going home, but I liked christopher's dress more. the bottom was amazing. the trench was okay and i can see the judges p.o.v too

lilkimbo 3 years

I agree with the loser, but I liked Althea's dress and thought she should have won. I also don't agree with Gordana being in the bottom three; her dress was one of my favorites!

Link Love

17 Comments