Do You Agree With Last Night's Project Runway Winner and Loser?

September 4, 2009

Last night on Project Runway, the designers headed to the beach for some ideas to make two surf-inspired looks. It wasn't my favorite episode ever. Guest judge Rachel Bilson looked cute but was a bit bland, and a lot of the outfits that went down the runway just confused me. In the end, I wholeheartedly agreed with the challenge loser and I thought the winner was OK, too. What about you — do you agree with the decisions made on the runway last night? After you vote, don't miss your last chance to fill out my Project Runway bracket!

Photos courtesy of Lifetime

17 Comments

fakeplanettelex 3 years 36 weeks

i wanted mitchell to go home last week - don't think the asian kid should've gone home (though i didn't agree w/making an "egg" dress for a pregnant woman, i liked that he had a unique point of view/concept) so i'm glad they finally got rid of him. as for the winner though, def agree it should've been christopher/logan's dress - that was very avant garde & beautiful.

fakeplanettelex 3 years 36 weeks

lizlee89 3 years 36 weeks

oh, and other than the macrame back of the beachy one and the bodice of the avant garde one; I did not like the other top scorers' (I don't know their names but I think the guy is Johnny and the girl is the really pretty one with long black hair) dresses - both and looked sloppy and lacked originality...

lizlee89 3 years 36 weeks

I absolutely completely agree with the loser - as bad as I felt for Mitchell when he went home; especially because he was an ok designer; his craftsmanship, focus, and work ethic were not on par with the other designers.I really liked both of Ramon's dresses; the green one was my favorite and the one I would wear, but I don't think it was not avant-garde enough. Althea and Louise had the best combo; both gorgeous, well-designed, and well-made; the beach dress was cute, young, and appropriate, and the avant garde dress was just that - over the top but still beautiful and wearable...

lizlee89 3 years 36 weeks

I absolutely completely agree with the loser - as bad as I felt for Mitchell when he went home; especially because he was an ok designer; his craftsmanship, focus, and work ethic were not on par with the other designers. I really liked both of Ramon's dresses; the green one was my favorite and the one I would wear, but I don't think it was not avant-garde enough. Althea and Louise had the best combo; both gorgeous, well-designed, and well-made; the beach dress was cute, young, and appropriate, and the avant garde dress was just that - over the top but still beautiful and wearable...

hil34 3 years 36 weeks

I would have loved Ramon's dress more if the gray wasn't so splotchy on the front. I liked it in the back though.

zeze 3 years 36 weeks

I agreed with the loser, way overdo. How did he get on this show?As for the winner, I think Ramon isn't a terrible choice since he put it all together alone and did nicely, but I though Shirin and and the blonde girl (something Hannah) were my favorite outfits.

zeze 3 years 36 weeks

I agreed with the loser, way overdo. How did he get on this show? As for the winner, I think Ramon isn't a terrible choice since he put it all together alone and did nicely, but I though Shirin and and the blonde girl (something Hannah) were my favorite outfits.

3 years 36 weeks

Mitchell did himself in, exploiting Ra'Mone and blowing it three weeks in a row. BUT I fundamentally dislike the emphasis Project Runway places on sewing skills. I think they need to be good enough to execute their vision so it can be judged, but beyond that I think they should only be judged on the design itself. Also, I wish Christopher & Logan's avant garde dress had won.

soulight 3 years 36 weeks

Ugh Mitchell... how did you get on this show? My mom was so confused last night when they were discussing his less than desirable sewing skills. She said "why would he apply for a show, if he can't sew. That's like your sister heading off to Top Chef, and we all know how sad those skills are." Yep, my mom burned my sister.

fashionplate525 3 years 36 weeks

Like most of the comments above, I agree Michael deserved to go home but I did not LOVE Ramon's dress all that much, certainly not as much as some of the other pieces.

billyart101 3 years 36 weeks

I agreed with the loser, but I didn't think the Avant Garde piece was that Avant Garde.

filmgirl81 3 years 36 weeks

yeah, I'm in agreement with the others about the winner and loser. It's funny how much us viewers agree on this stuff. makes me wonder what's going on in the show.

shmoo15 3 years 36 weeks

I agree with the loser, not the winner. Mitchel was pure laze. how the hell did he even make it on the show?

sumbum 3 years 36 weeks

YES, I wholeheartedly agree that the loser deserved to go home. 1. He hasn't really done anything spectacular (or finished) yet - Hello, remember the collar disaster. 2. He admitted ON AIR that he chose Ra'mon b/c Ra'mon could carry him through the next challenge. He was just yapping away, letting Ra'mon do all the work. Ra'mon is totally stressing out, doing both pieces! Where's the teamwork? More specifically, where's the work?