BuzzSugar and PopSugar Pick the American Idol Top 12

American Idol Snap Judgments: Pop and Buzz Pick the Top 12


Updated 02/15/08 11:55 AM · Posted by BuzzSugar · 15 comments

American Idol announced its top 24 last night, and that can only mean one thing: It's time for irrational predictions! Last year, Pop and I faced off with our snap judgments about which of the 24 semi-finalists would make it to the finals, and we had so much fun taunting each other about it that we decided to do it again this time around.

This year's a little tricky because we've hardly seen half of these guys, and a few of the girls haven't had much screen time, either. But no matter — that's what gut feelings are for, right? To see which guys and girls we each think will make it through, just push play:

For our full lists plus pictures of all the contestants, just read more.

The Guys Chikezie Eze — Buzz & Pop Colton Berry — Neither Danny Noriega — Buzz & Pop David Archuleta — Buzz & Pop David Cook — Neither David Hernandez — Pop Garrett Haley — Neither Jason Castro — Buzz Jason Yeager — Neither Luke Menard — Neither Michael Johns — Buzz & Pop Robbie Carrico — Buzz & Pop The Ladies Alaina Whitaker — Neither Alexandrea “Alex” Lushington — Buzz Amanda L. Overmyer — Buzz Amy Davis — Neither Asia'H Epperson — Buzz Brooke White — Buzz & Pop Carly Smithson — Buzz & Pop Joanne Borgella — Pop Kady Malloy — Pop Kristy Lee Cook — Neither Ramiele Malubay — Buzz & Pop Syesha Mercado — Pop Photo courtesy of Fox
Join The Conversation: Sign Up or Sign In
powered by
Please sign in to comment.