Skip Nav

BuzzSugar and PopSugar Pick the American Idol Top 12

American Idol Snap Judgments: Pop and Buzz Pick the Top 12

American Idol announced its top 24 last night, and that can only mean one thing: It's time for irrational predictions! Last year, Pop and I faced off with our snap judgments about which of the 24 semi-finalists would make it to the finals, and we had so much fun taunting each other about it that we decided to do it again this time around.

This year's a little tricky because we've hardly seen half of these guys, and a few of the girls haven't had much screen time, either. But no matter — that's what gut feelings are for, right? To see which guys and girls we each think will make it through, just push play:

For our full lists plus pictures of all the contestants, just read more.


aIdol_Alexandrea23_027abrF

aIdol_Alaina12_007abrF

aIdol_DavidA03_012abrF

aIdol_Amy19_018abrF

aIdol_Carly11_021abrF

aIdol_Chickeze18_019abrF

aIdol_Ashia14_022abrF

aIdol_Danny05_025abrF

aIdol_DavidH16_028abrF

aIdol_Garrett24_006abrF

aIdol_JasonYeager06_025abrF

aIdol_JoAnne08_010abrF

aIdol_Amanda17_016abrF

aIdol_JasonCastro01_009abrL3F

aIdol_Kady21_026abrF

aIdol_Kristy10_040abrF

aIdol_Luke15_006abrF

aIdol_Michael13_008abrF

aIdol_Robbie04_002abrF

aIdol_Sayesha20_066abrF

aIdol_DavidCGallery2_0421abrF

aIdol_ColtonGallery2_0283abrF

aIdol_BrookeGallery2_0220abrF

aIdol_RamielleGallery2_0118abrF

The Guys
Chikezie Eze — Buzz & Pop
Colton Berry — Neither
Danny Noriega — Buzz & Pop
David Archuleta — Buzz & Pop
David Cook — Neither
David Hernandez — Pop
Garrett Haley — Neither
Jason Castro — Buzz
Jason Yeager — Neither
Luke Menard — Neither
Michael Johns — Buzz & Pop
Robbie Carrico — Buzz & Pop

The Ladies
Alaina Whitaker — Neither
Alexandrea “Alex” Lushington — Buzz
Amanda L. Overmyer — Buzz
Amy Davis — Neither
Asia'H Epperson — Buzz
Brooke White — Buzz & Pop
Carly Smithson — Buzz & Pop
Joanne Borgella — Pop
Kady Malloy — Pop
Kristy Lee Cook — Neither
Ramiele Malubay — Buzz & Pop
Syesha Mercado — Pop

Photo courtesy of Fox

Latest

Download our new Selfie app!

+