American Idol Top 8 Recap 2011-04-14 07:52:24

American Idol: The Top 8 Take On Movie Night

April 14, 2011

1 / 11

American Idol's top eight contestants looked to their cinematic favorites to pick a song for movie night. Everyone seems to still be reeling from Pia's elimination last week, giving the competition more of a feeling that no one is safe. The judges were scant on criticism this week, but we're not — check out my recap of each performance and then vote on who you think is still in the game, and who's on their way out.

Photos courtesy of Fox

1 / 11

by Shannon Vestal 6

Photos courtesy of Fox

‹ Back to Homepage

popsugar live!

NOW

Click to watch POPSUGAR Live! now!

6 Comments

bingbingboom 2 years 5 weeks

I really find Haley's performance style annoying.

Katie Henry 2 years 5 weeks

Becky, no way! End of the Road was my jam back in the day and Stefano totally rocked it. I'm fearful for the ladies...again.

care0531 2 years 5 weeks

I think it's the "End of the Road" for Stefano...pun intended :)

Mad Woman 2 years 5 weeks

I LOVED Casey last night! And no, I'm not reeling from Pia's boot. While ALL of her songs showcased her beautiful voice, they were poor choices for the fans, IMO. Unfortunately, I agree with the judges this week, Haley did NOT bring her A game last night. I love her voice but last night was hard to watch.

Mad Woman 2 years 5 weeks

I LOVED Casey last night! And no, I'm not reeling from Pia's boot. While ALL of her songs showcased her beautiful voice, they were poor choices for the fans, IMO.Unfortunately, I agree with the judges this week, Haley did NOT bring her A game last night. I love her voice but last night was hard to watch.