"American Idol" Top 12: Who's Going Home?

19 Comments

I almost feel bad for Gina, she was so shoved into that "tween rock" box. It really doesn't suit her.

sanjaya just needs to go. he's not going to bring anything new to the stage. it's been the same pretty much this entire time. it's just his charm and his smile that keeps people voting for him. it's time for him to go. haley scarnato or whatever her name is was terrible. i hated every single second of it. i think simon was being brainwashed by her beauty or something when he was giving her positive feedback. i mean when something is that bad, you're supposed to be extra brutal simon. i think it was chris richardson who he was very negative towards.. and he wasn't half as bad as haley. melinda, lakisha and jordin were amazinggggg. i especially love jordin. when she sang it was amazing. she also has a great smile. haha.

Livvy-P 6 years 9 weeks

I voted for Sanjaya to be sent home, but unfortunately, I think he is going to stick around another week. That was such a painful performance to watch! I still can't believe that he got more votes than Sundance (who wasn't the best, but is without a doubt better than him!!) Anyway, I feel like Brandon did a kind of crappy job, and Haley was a MESS but people feel sorry for her, & vote! She seems like a sweet person, but not AI star material... Stephanie wasn't too great (not as great as usual), and I actually fear for her! She has talent. Finally, I seem to be in the minority, but I really like Gina. I love her attitude, and her look, and the the whole vibe that she is rocking! She makes it fun. But I agree with almost everyone else - I think that this is between Melinda & Lakisha - AMAZING, both of them. They took so-so songs by Diana Ross and made them incredible, & memorable. BTW, why didn't anyone pick I'm Coming Out? Love that song!

DABRATLEXI04 6 years 9 weeks

ok, blake is adorable and a great singer and i kinda sorta like wat he did to the song. brandon 4got the words and was pitchy. Chris Richardson is just hot wit a great voice and ppl luv him (especially us gurlzzz ;-) ) but i dont think he did 2 good last nite, but there were worse ppl. chris sligh was just ALRIGHT. gina was good. haley 4got the words twice and was very pitchy and u could hear her voice shaking. jordin was awesome!! melinda was AMAZING as usual. theres NO WAY she going home. lakisha was amazing as well. and she looked really pretty. phil was alright, but he tends 2 yell when he has to belt out. stephanie was good. shes always good. but every1 was anticipating tha big disco part, which we never got! and dont even get me started on sanjaya! he was chosen over SUNDANCE!! how dare they! america was b stupid or their TVs must've been on mute when sundace sang that night! sanjaya's hair was horrible, and u could barely hear him singing over the band! sanjaya MUST GO!!! ♥

yiddidea 6 years 9 weeks

I think people who waste their time on it are people who hate American Idol and want to see it fail. I think it is ridiculous. If you don't like it, don't watch it. It is pretty simple.

t_hive88 6 years 9 weeks

I can't believe people actually listen to votefortheworst. Why would you waste your time on that?? I check out that site every now and then, but I'm going to vote for a person that I can actually see myself buying their cd.

POPSUGAR Entertainment 6 years 9 weeks

I think Vote for the Worst is some of it, definitely. But as we saw with Sundance and Antonella, they can't do it alone. So seriously — who else is voting for this kid?

yiddidea 6 years 9 weeks

Sanjaya is getting support from www.votefortheworst.com, so he may be sticking around for a while...

t_hive88 6 years 9 weeks

I don't feel sorry for him, but I do feel sorry for the people that are going home instead of him! GO HOME SANJAYA!

IowaGirl 6 years 9 weeks

i thought Sanjaya should have gone home a few weeks back. He's popular with SOMEONE. But, i would also like to see Phil leave, i just don't get it. I don't think he's that great at all. alright, now i have to go to the you tube to check it out...i didn't see his earrings (i didn't pay too much attention to him at all). I just felt a little sorry for him.

cine_lover 6 years 9 weeks

Is it just me or does anyone else dislike Gina??? I can't stand the girl. I just want her to go away!!!

t_hive88 6 years 9 weeks

Did anyone notice Sanjaya's earrings?? I don't even wear earrings that dangle like that!

LuckyGrl 83 6 years 9 weeks

hehehe... he kinda looked line a Diana Ross in training... poor thing... those stylists on A.I. can be evil sometimes :)

calibabi 6 years 9 weeks

i think there are a number of people who should feel vulnerable tonight. namely brandon, sanjaya, and haley. phil might also be going.

workinggirl83 6 years 9 weeks

Ha ha! Ya, Sanjaya's hair looked like they pin curled in before the show, let it loose, spritzed it with hair spray and ta-da! Kind of like what I do to my hair every day, but I'm a girl :(

yiddidea 6 years 9 weeks

I missed the show last night but thanks to YouTube I was able to catch up. Sanjaya's hair made me literally laugh out loud at my desk. WTF?