American Idol Top 11: Who's Going Home Next?

27 Comments

are we ever going to get a chance to see dabid cook do something other than head banging rock and roll. come on america there is more to music than hard rock. same with amanda she couldn't do a 3 second solo with the group singing either. now lets see if cook can do anything else if not be gone cook.

orisugar 5 years 9 weeks

David Archuleta is the idol this season! LOVE HIM! I can't wait to get his songs on itunes!

nadya226 5 years 9 weeks

Im i the only one who thinks that Paula Abdul needs to go, what does she contribute to the show besides being irrelevant??

Maggie Mae 5 years 9 weeks

Ack! KLC made it another week!

Maggie Mae 5 years 9 weeks

I am totally surprised that Ramiele just made the top 10 and Carly is in the bottom 3.

californiagirlx7 5 years 9 weeks

I hope its Amanda Overmyer of Kristy Lee Cook. Chikezie and Ramiele bug me a little bit too.

Meka_suga 5 years 9 weeks

I love Ramiele and Syesha Mercado.

Mykie7 5 years 9 weeks

OH, Gotta put in my vote for my girl, GOOOOOO BROOKE WHITE! She's so awesome. She definitely needs work on her stage presence, but she sang the song beautifully, and like Paula and Randy both said, the stage presence will come.

Mykie7 5 years 9 weeks

BYE KRISTY! I was so hoping it would be a case of "Hometown girl makes good" but instead it was a case of "Hometown girl makes you barf." :(

mamaseacat 5 years 9 weeks

Kristy will probably go home although I wish Ramiele would. I'm not a big Ramiele fan but she's got every Filipino in the country voting for her - just like Jasmine Trias. My parents are big Ramiele fans because she's Filipino. "We hab to bote por her beecos she is juan ob us."

TwinMommy 5 years 9 weeks

I think Kristy, Ramiele, and Amanda need to go. They all suck. David Cook is amazingly talented and kinda sexy IMO (I went nuts over his version of Hello), BUT I did notice his "cockiness" last night. He's getting a little too confident and I hope he doesn't keep it up because people will get annoyed and start voting against him. (I'm in Canada and so wish I could vote!!!!!!)

princess_eab 5 years 9 weeks

Hey, I agree with both sides here..... I'm in the camp that hates Amanda (she's getting boring) and in the Kristy-hating camp. For some reason this year there don't seem to be many contestants that are exciting to watch.

cherrygirl143 5 years 9 weeks

I so surprised to see everyone anti-Kristy...Amanda is pure torture!!!! You can't understand her, she basically just screams the lyics and never looks happy!

luckyme 5 years 9 weeks

I love The Beatles, but not on American Idol. They seriously need to stop. And of course Kristy Lee Cook is out. That was really bad.

millarci 5 years 9 weeks

It's time for Kristy to go. She's has had dodged the bullet too many times.

j2e1n9 5 years 9 weeks

She's a very attractive girl, and not a bad voice, but nothing special about it. Also, she just doesnt have "IT". And you cant fake "IT". I mean, Amanda has more IT than she does. :OY:

stina829 5 years 9 weeks

Am I the only one who thinks Kristy Lee looked a lot like a young Melissa Etheridge last night? Or a young Muriel Hemingway? Maybe I'm nuts. And I said LOOKED like her, not sounded like her. (NOOO Way! lol)

aoitenshi 5 years 9 weeks

Kristy Lee Cook has to go! She's awful.

sweetrae80 5 years 9 weeks

i think KLC's voice is beautiful but she moves around like a mannequin. i voted for jason castro though because his voice is really not that good. he just gets the teen girl vote because he is a cutie (not feeling the hair though).

laneylaney 5 years 9 weeks

Why does Kristy Lee annoy me so much? I feel bad!

Maggie Mae 5 years 9 weeks

It just hurts to watch/ hear KLC every week. Her dress was great last night, but then they panned down to those awful boots. And then we had to hear her sing. I'm just not a fan.