American Idol Predictions For the Top Five on Rat Pack Night

Which American Idol Contestant Is Going Home?

April 28, 2009

1 / 7

The five remaining American Idol contestants tried to play it cool on Tuesday by singing songs made famous by the original Rat Pack. Of course, only four can advance to the next round. We're really getting down to the wire here, so tell me: Can Allison keep the ladies' hopes alive? Can Matt continue to make the judges glad they saved him? Which contestant will be heading home this week?

Photos courtesy of Fox

1 / 7

by POPSUGAR Entertainment 14

Photos courtesy of Fox

‹ Back to Homepage

popsugar live!

NOW

Click to watch POPSUGAR Live! now!

14 Comments

4 years 3 weeks

It's between Adam and Allison when it comes down to it! Matt is going home tonight as well as Danny... he was screaming that song at us last night. Adam is the next ELVIS! in my opinion. Think about it!

4 years 3 weeks

I really didn’t love last night. I was actually really bored watching it… Kris Allen sang “The Way You Look Tonight”, which is one of the only songs I actually knew. I really like Kris. He is consistent every week and his voice doesn’t change so he is definitely talented. I think Simon was wrong saying he couldn’t win the whole thing. He may come out of no where. Allison Iraheta sang "Someone to Watch Over Me". She seemed really nervous for some reason and I think everyone could see it. It seems like she’s really trying for people to like her now though. I wish I had her voice! Matt Giraud sang "My Funny Valentine." I thought he was going to be a lot better because he went to school for jazz. But man I thought it was horrible, he is so pitchy. I think he killed himself when he told everyone he was excited for this week and then sucked! But I am glad he has been wearing his hat more cause I can’t bare to look at that wart/mole thing he has on his forehead! Danny Gokey sang "Come Rain or Come Shine." I think the performance might have been his best. The way he ended it was awesome and it seemed like he finally had some confidence. His raspy voice went well with the song. But people have kept him around cause of his situation… I am pretty sure of it! Adam Lambert sang "Feeling Good" He is so good. He looked so good. He sang so good. I loved the white suit on him. He just knows how to perform. He blows most of the others out of the water. If he didn’t know how to use lighting and stuff I don’t think he would’ve made it this far based on his voice. He just knows how to do it. Adam was my favorite of the night. He hasn’t been my favorite in awhile. I think Matt and Allison will be the bottom two… with Matt going home. I wish they wouldn’t have used that stupid save on him!

care0531 4 years 3 weeks

I really wish Danny would get the boot but I think it will be Allison or Matt just because they were in the bottom before. Kris might be in the bottom too.

4 years 3 weeks

Adam SHOULD go home. All of his songs sound exactly alike, he is boring, I cant stand him because to me he disrespects every style of music, take your crazy self packing! Kris and Danny are my picks, love them both.

lemuse20 4 years 3 weeks

I want Gokey to go home, but I think Matt will... which is okay because he was just okay this week too.

pinkprincess1101 4 years 3 weeks

I think it will be Matt or at least it should, the others are pretty much consistent and good, Adam for me did well twice and last night I felt like his singing was way off.

4 years 3 weeks

Well I must be one of "your kind," 'cause I cannot STAND Adam. He probably won't be going home tomorrow night though, so I'm going to guess it's Matt or Allison.

4 years 3 weeks

Adam was amazing! All the haters are coming out of the wood work. It is sooo funny. Kris made my ears bleed he should go but Matt, Danny or Allison will probably be sent packing.

missbrooke09 4 years 3 weeks

I think Matt is most likely to be leaving, but Simon pretty much threw Allison and Kris under the bus, so I wouldn't be surprised if either of them were to leave. I REALLY want the hokey gokey to go. Ugh. I get more and more annoyed with him every week. Put the GO in Gokey. I don't want to see any of them but Danny go.

missbrooke09 4 years 3 weeks

I think Matt is most likely to be leaving, but Simon pretty much threw Allison and Kris under the bus, so I wouldn't be surprised if either of them were to leave.I REALLY want the hokey gokey to go. Ugh. I get more and more annoyed with him every week. Put the GO in Gokey.I don't want to see any of them but Danny go.

misscococherie 4 years 3 weeks

Well i'm a supporter of Kris Allen since the last 4 weeks, every week he's upping the bar for me. I hope he makes it to the end. I know i'm going to be burned for this but if Danny wins i won't watch American Idol again. The guy sure there are some songs he did that were okay but seriously the judges glorify him to much. that's just my opinion