American Idol Elimination Predictions for the Top 7 on Disco Night

Which Two American Idol Contestants are Going Home?

April 21, 2009

1 / 10

The seven remaining American Idol contestants put their spin on disco hits on Tuesday night. The performances were particularly crucial: Because the judges used their save on Matt Giraud last week, not one but two Idol hopefuls will be going home on Wednesday. So which two failed to make disco their own? Take a spin through these polls to tell me who's heading home.

Photos courtesy of Fox

1 / 10

by POPSUGAR Entertainment 20

Photos courtesy of Fox

‹ Back to Homepage

popsugar live!

NOW

Click to watch POPSUGAR Live! now!

20 Comments

californiagirlx7 4 years 4 weeks

I think Lil and Anoop should go home, but I wouldn't be sad if Matt went home instead of Anoop. It's definitely Lil's time to go though.To this day, I still don't understand the fascination with Adam. I think his voice is decent and he can definitely sing, but his high-pitched screams are annoying. He seems more suited to Broadway (which is appropriate since he used to be in the production of Wicked in LA). I'm still waiting for Danny to knock it out of the park too, but I love his voice and I still can't get his performance of "PYT" out of my head. I'm kinda attracted to him too ;) Kris Allen is definitely a front-runner right now and I think he should be in the top 2 or 3.

californiagirlx7 4 years 4 weeks

I think Lil and Anoop should go home, but I wouldn't be sad if Matt went home instead of Anoop. It's definitely Lil's time to go though. To this day, I still don't understand the fascination with Adam. I think his voice is decent and he can definitely sing, but his high-pitched screams are annoying. He seems more suited to Broadway (which is appropriate since he used to be in the production of Wicked in LA). I'm still waiting for Danny to knock it out of the park too, but I love his voice and I still can't get his performance of "PYT" out of my head. I'm kinda attracted to him too ;) Kris Allen is definitely a front-runner right now and I think he should be in the top 2 or 3.

karina01 4 years 4 weeks

For me, the bottom three should be Lil, Anoop, and Matt. and for the 2 that will be going home, well, its obvious...Lil and Anoop

Taylormayde26 4 years 4 weeks

my feelings are for Lil and possibly Kris or Matt are going home this week !! I really love Danny he can't leave the competition at this point . I would be sad that Danny gets voted off...!!( I really like him he's never been in the bottom 3 not once but please god keep him in the competition !! I truly believe it's gonna be Lil and Matt or Kris or possibly Anoop going home this week!! my bets are Lil and Matt but who knows!!( in a sad way I really like Matt too. but I wanna say "Lil and Anoop" should go home!! my top 5 if the cards are right: Alison, Danny, Adam ,Kris and Matt but this could easily change !!)

Taylormayde26 4 years 4 weeks

my feelings are for Lil and possibly Kris or Matt are going home this week !! I really love Danny he can't leave the competition at this point . I would be sad that Danny gets voted off...!!( I really like him he's never been in the bottom 3 not once but please god keep him in the competition !! I truly believe it's gonna be Lil and Matt or Kris or possibly Anoop going home this week!! my bets are Lil and Matt but who knows!!( in a sad way I really like Matt too. but I wanna say "Lil and Anoop" should go home!!my top 5 if the cards are right: Alison, Danny, Adam ,Kris and Matt but this could easily change !!)

LilyBiscuit7 4 years 4 weeks

probably Lil and Anoop

LilyBiscuit7 4 years 4 weeks

probably Lil and Anoop

care0531 4 years 4 weeks

skigirl its funny you say that about Matt's looks because I think he is talented but I wonder if he had more sex appeal if more people would vote for him.Kris I think is an okay singer- he can't hit the high notes and I would compare him to a John Mayer if that good, but he's cute and the ladies love him for that.At the end of the day its who has the talent to sell the most albums.

care0531 4 years 4 weeks

skigirl its funny you say that about Matt's looks because I think he is talented but I wonder if he had more sex appeal if more people would vote for him. Kris I think is an okay singer- he can't hit the high notes and I would compare him to a John Mayer if that good, but he's cute and the ladies love him for that. At the end of the day its who has the talent to sell the most albums.

skigurl 4 years 4 weeks

the votes seem to agree that LIL will for sure go, and the debate for the other is Anoop and Matt....frankly I feel it would be unfair to send Anoop home when Matt was already given the axe last week....i just fear Anoop doesn't have the fanbase to keep him in....that said, Matt's only appeal is looking like an uglier Justin Timberlake and so i can never see him being famous because he will never be quite as good at JT!

mga1115 4 years 4 weeks

I think Lil and Anoop should be the ones to go

ktc71 4 years 4 weeks

I'm hoping its Lil and Anoop that get sent home.

LaurenG22 4 years 4 weeks

Lil, Danny, Anoop- bottom three. I only care that Lil goes home. She needs to make her EXIT. Adam and Kris were my favorite! Alison was so so at best, but she can definitely sing. Matt was fine, not the best, but definitely NOT the worst. I liked his song.

care0531 4 years 4 weeks

I was actually happy with almost every performance last night. I have not been an Adam fan but after last night I decided that hands down he will win this season. Dial Idol for the first time this season are saying that the voting is actually too close to call this week. They had Lil at the top of the leader board but thought there might have been a problem with filters her calls. They had at the top last week when she was in the bottom so I am hoping for the same results this week because she was the only performance that I didn't enjoy at all. With Lil at the top they have Kris and Allison at the bottom- I think we might be saying good bye to the 2 ladies tonight but I am hoping that isn't true. Anoop and Lil need to go!

care0531 4 years 4 weeks

I was actually happy with almost every performance last night. I have not been an Adam fan but after last night I decided that hands down he will win this season.Dial Idol for the first time this season are saying that the voting is actually too close to call this week. They had Lil at the top of the leader board but thought there might have been a problem with filters her calls. They had at the top last week when she was in the bottom so I am hoping for the same results this week because she was the only performance that I didn't enjoy at all.With Lil at the top they have Kris and Allison at the bottom- I think we might be saying good bye to the 2 ladies tonight but I am hoping that isn't true.Anoop and Lil need to go!

missbrooke09 4 years 4 weeks

I would LOVE it if Lil and Danny were sent home. But I think it'll probably be Lil and Anoop.Lil NEEDS to go home. She doesn't deserve to be there over everyone else.I'd be okay with anyone other than Kris, Adam and Matt leaving. Out of those three, I think Matt's in the most trouble, but he may be able to rally enough votes to keep him safe for another week. At least I hope so.

missbrooke09 4 years 4 weeks

I would LOVE it if Lil and Danny were sent home. But I think it'll probably be Lil and Anoop. Lil NEEDS to go home. She doesn't deserve to be there over everyone else. I'd be okay with anyone other than Kris, Adam and Matt leaving. Out of those three, I think Matt's in the most trouble, but he may be able to rally enough votes to keep him safe for another week. At least I hope so.

baybeelurv 4 years 4 weeks

I would like to congrat to the contestants for making this very special moment for me as it the serious part for the my intention to watch this beautiful american idol . however i would link my explanation of love to my dear Kris alen. you know kris' when the time you appear on the stage my love grows old , why im saying that is because you and i are the true friendship. forever and ever my love for u never dies.AMEN

zeze 4 years 4 weeks

After last week I am afraid it is going to be Matt. Anoop is doing well with the ballads and has a following, as forgettable and boring as he is. Lil HAS to be the other one.I'm also a little worried for Allison, she didn't do much for me this week.Adam (who I actually liked tonight because he didn't scream as much) is safe, so is Gokey, who, if you ask me was bottom 3 material in my book. Kris was my favorite this week, LOVED that song. (But Matt is still my favorite)!

zeze 4 years 4 weeks

After last week I am afraid it is going to be Matt. Anoop is doing well with the ballads and has a following, as forgettable and boring as he is. Lil HAS to be the other one. I'm also a little worried for Allison, she didn't do much for me this week. Adam (who I actually liked tonight because he didn't scream as much) is safe, so is Gokey, who, if you ask me was bottom 3 material in my book. Kris was my favorite this week, LOVED that song. (But Matt is still my favorite)!