For last Wednesday's Recast challenge [0], I asked you guys to choose a whole new cast for the John Hughes classic, The Breakfast Club [1]. This was by far the most wildly popular Recast challenge yet, and there were so many good ideas. I particularly loved PinkRabbit's [2] pick for Frankie Muniz to play the geek role originated by Anthony Michael Hall, and I was pleasantly surprised by Honeysugar28 [3] choosing Scarlett Johansson for the Molly Ringwald part.

But the best list overall came from Swwonder [4], who really nailed it with an ideal mix of young actors or actors who just look young. Here are her picks, complete with a "new" cast photo.

Claire Standish (The Princess) — Mandy Moore
Andy Clark (The Jock) — Chad Michael Murray
Brian Johnson (The Geek) — Adam Brody
John Bender (The Rebel) — James Franco
Allison Reynolds (The Basket Case) — Anna Paquin

Tune in tomorrow for another Recast challenge [5]!

Source [6]