
It seems like this is quickly becoming the redemption season for Grey's Anatomy — not just for the show, but for its characters, too. Last week, Meredith acted like a normal person for the first time in forever; in this episode, Izzie was actually allowed to be a competent surgeon. What's next, George getting a backbone? To read my thoughts on this episode, just read more
First, let me take a moment to praise Brooke Smith as Dr. Hahn. Her "Are you two a couple?" to Mark and Derek was one of the funniest things I've heard in a while. And while I thought her glass ceiling speech to the Chief about his "Gentleman's Evening" was a little over the top, it did reveal one very important thing about her character: She doesn't want to be "one of the guys;" she wants to be taken seriously for the powerful woman she is. Team Hahn, all the way.
It didn't hurt that she got a great case in her first episode. Awake open-heart surgery — aside from being amazingly freaky — is a perfect story for Grey's, because we learn so much from the way the doctors interact with patients. Hahn's still holding her grudge against Cristina, but that was fine by me, because it let us see Izzie do something well. Izzie isn't hardcore, but she can relate to people, and she proved it by setting up her patient's operating room and talking him through the surgery. The "describe the people in the gallery" scene went on too long — is that why they extended the episode? — but it was sweet. I like competent Izzie, and I hope she sticks around.

After months of not dealing with anything, Meredith has done a complete 180 into constant introspection. Everything out of her mouth these days seems to be about dying, and I'm almost regretting all those times I called for Meredith to just talk about it already. But not quite. Because just as I like competent Izzie, I also like the version of Meredith who tries to deal with what's going on around her. Treating the patient (hi, Roy from The Office!) who survived a 12,000-foot free fall was good for her; even though she didn't use her own fearless time well, she could at least urge someone else to take advantage of the feeling.
Some other thoughts:
- The wedding dress plot was ridiculous, but even it had some good things going for it, like Mark humiliating George on Callie's behalf and Lexie proving herself by talking the one bride-to-be into having surgery. But is Callie really letting go?
- Gizzie-sex is delayed, but still seems inevitable. Also, Izzie's tearful breakdown made me uncomfortable, but that might have been because of the strange top she was wearing.
- Speaking of sex: Man, do I wish I had taken bets on how long it would take Lexie to sleep with a Seattle Grace doctor. Six episodes ain't bad, but considering that her sister slept with one before she even started working, she's got some catching up to do.
- I am so annoyed with Derek. He's upset that it's not his job "anymore" to take care of Meredith? Has he not been dating the same woman we've been watching for three years?
- I love the idea of the Chief living in a trailer; remember when he took his suitcase camping?
What did you think? Wishing the other woman had won the dress contest? Disappointed there was no actual kung fu fighting in an episode titled "Kung Fu Fighting"? Sound off below.
Photos copyright 2007 ABC, Inc.

















T-Bags
Stila
Pied A Terre
I was very pleased this week. The best parts - Lexie telling the wedding dress woman that she will have a hunchback, Cristina telling Shephard that she is taking care of Meredith, and Izzie crying because she was tired and George asking if she only shaved one leg.
1I loved it when Hahn called Sloan & Shepherd ... Pretty & Prettier. I actually was contemplating in my mind which was which.
2i was SO glad the blonde girl didn't win the contest...she whined too much.
and i cannot deal with alex and lexie....i need alex and izzie back together!!!!!
and i missed bailey this episode.
3I love sloan
4i'm not happy with karev hookin up with lexie
oh and lol yeah i love the Chief living in a trailer with 'em too LOL so funny @ the end where they were all playin monopoly with Hahn
5i thought that the blonde bride was awful. So happy she didn't win... but I thought we were going to find out the other bride's story was a lie just to get the dress.
LOVE Pretty and Prettier, but totally thought Hahn's speech to the Chief was over the top, and inappropriate. if he wants to hang out with friends then so be it. there are plenty of other department heads that weren't invited to "gentleman's night".
Can Meredith and Derek just be happy together. I would not get bored of watching them be a happy couple.
6I kind of like Lexie and Alex together, though I think she's too sweet for him. The patient having awake open heart surgery was pretty amazing, and I really liked the way Izzie handled his freakout and the way she prepared the operating room. I was cringing at the thought that he was getting so wound up he might actually jump off the table or something. Izzie crying because she was too tired to have sex with George and because she only shaved one leg was pretty adorable too. She slightly redeemed herself in this episode for me
7yay for a strong female character! I'm totally on Team Hahn. And YAY that that Callie's bride didn't get the wedding. Bridezilla all the way - gross.
Loved Mark and Derek - as always. Loved the monopoly. And I love that Mere is processing. I'm not sure where Derek's head is at - he seems to be creating drama for himself and isn't that meredith's job?
Anyway - bravo to grey's for redeeming itself.
8I love love looooove Dr. Hahn. Finally we have a female attending who provides some much-needed snark. I'm so glad she's here to stay!
9Love the show. Always will, but tired of the "everyone sleeps with everyone" story lines. I thought Alex was in love with Ava/Rebecca? How quickly he swapped beds. Izzie and George...I see the end coming soon - seriously. I see George backing away from both Izzie and Callie. Maybe someone new entirely? Lexi maybe? Dunno, but it sure seemed like the failed attempt at sex last night between George and Izzie is the writer's getting us ready for another failed relationship. They just don't work together truly. Callie and Sloan...now there's a relationship I'd like to see develop. It was a good show last night, just disappointed with some of the choices. I loved George's line last night when he was talking to one of the brides questioning his marital status, "I don't know you well enough to discuss this with you." LOL!
10i love that meredith is figuring thing out. it's about time that she started talking about her dying. also, i like the part when she was talking to cristina about tderek and that she soesn't want to let him go or something to that effect.
and then there's dr. hahn and her comment about pretty and prettier and then when she asked if derek and mark were a couple. that had me laughing so hard. also, i like that she ended up hanging out with them during gentlemen's night.
oh and also, i like that the chief lives on derek's land in a trailer. it's just amusing being that in the episode when they went fishing, her brought a suitcase. i also like that in the end the chief and the attendings were playing monopoly... i thought they'd be playing poker or something.
i could have cared less about the scenes with lexie and alex and izzy and george together. i think if they would have taken thouse scene out, it wouldn't have made a difference.
i felt bad for callie but i like how mark is taking her side and backing her up...
11I am glad Alex and Lexie got together from here on out i am calling them,,,,,,
ALEXIE.
12ALEXIE! good one
i agree w/ keck_la though
13"I thought Alex was in love with Ava/Rebecca? How quickly he swapped beds."
Oh my hubby says "you dont shave your legs before nookie" and i said "those days are over" HA HA
14I loved the McDreamy/McSteamy moments this week! Oh and, "pretty and prettier" and "are you a couple?" lol.
Derek with the sad eyes was... sad
Hahn didn't annoy me this week as much as she usually does, but that speech to the chief... why? Didn't make any sense.
15I really liked this episode. Asking if Sloan/Derek were a couple and their reaction was HI-larious. I don't like the Lexie/Alex hook-up, nor did I like Meredith's reaction in the preview, but I can deal with it as long as the season keeps going the way it's going.
16My husband says he's back on board. I'm not so sure. Yes, it's getting better but please don't make me watch George and Izzie have hot sex. And show me more Dr. Bailey as she is the best aspect of the whole show.
17I love Dr. Hahn. I miss Burke but she is a great replacement for him. I also loved how she is totally being hard on Cristina, but I can't wait until she finds out that Izzie was the one who cut Denny's lvad wire. As for Lexi sleeping with Alex...ewww. What the hell happen to him being in love with Ava.
18Great recap, Buzz! Grey's really is redeeming itself this season. Like others, I loved the "pretty and prettier" comment from Dr. Hahn and her "are you a couple?" question as well. Brooke Smith is an excellent addition to the cast. Looking forward to watching her develop and interact with the residents throughout the rest of the season. And, for once, I really did like Izzie; she may not be a hardcore surgeon, but she is a competent, caring doctor. Hope Bailey and Hahn get a chance to interact in future episodes; that would be real competition.
19I just started watching this show last week to prepare for when Pacey starts in a few weeks. I've never watched it before that. I can't stand Meredith Grey-- why on earth anyone ever thought it was a good idea to develop a show around someone as wimpy, self-obsessed and unlikeable as her is beyond me.
The Izzie crying thing was weird-- why didn't she just tell George she was too tired? Was a breakdown really called for?
Callie and Christina are my favorites so far. I like a strong, capable woman. I'm hoping Pacey becomes a love interest for one of these two-- Pacey always did like his gals feisty.
I wasn't sure how I felt about Hahn's feminist speech-- I feel like the show was making an attempt to be feminist, but why didn't the doctor (don't know his name) just explain to her that they wanted to have ONE boys weekend, and they don't have a habit of having 'boys-club' outings all the time (or do they?)
Mainly, my thoughts are please God, don't let Pacey hook-up with Meredith 'basket-case' Grey.
20The way McSteamy was looking at Hahn the whole episode long, especially during the "Are you a couple?"-scene... I don't think he will hook up with Callie, I think he will develop a crush on Hahn. He likes strong females, like Addison. And Hahn is ONE!
21I don't know if I take any more of Meredith's introspection and her questioning her relationship with Derek. Seriously, I think this has been the theme of the show since it started, and its just pathetic and old. I actually stop skip the scenes with Meredith b/c its just annoying to hear her talk about herself anymore. Just move on!
But I do like the Izzie and George storyline, and I'm interested to see where it goes. I think Hahn is a great addition, but I'm still skeptical with this show. They lost me with the whole 3 part episode when Meredith has her "near death experience", and who knows if they can ever come back from that...
22Mainly, my thoughts are please God, don't let Pacey hook-up with Meredith 'basket-case' Grey.

23i'm with you on that !!! brittanybe
it's official: i'm done with this show.
from dumb, annoying patients (seriously... the wedding gown made me want to choke both those stupid women... way to make us look like superficial freaks when it comes to our weddings, shonda) to dumb, annoying doctors (everyone except dr. hahn), i cannot take the hot mess this show has become.
watching gizzie is like watching two cousins have sex--gross and wrong. i hate them both now. meredith is more annoying now than she has ever been talking about her feelings, and her sister is just as bad if not worse in her naivete. i loathe how villanized christina STILL is, even though she is one of the only ones with focus, drive, and ambition for her career who doesn't whine constantly.
this episode was like nails on a chalkboard for me, and i just can't take it anymore. i give up.
24I really need to never see George and Izzie talking about sex. Seriously. Just, it borders on incest, ok?
I can't imagine anyone being able to say no to a romp in the sack with Alex, so, uh, yeah. Can't hate on Lexie for taking her chance.
I missed a few eps here and there, but what is Hahn's grudge against Cristina? Didn't Izzie steal her patient's heart??
25ugh! the only thing i DIDN'T like about this episode was the alex/lexie thing. first of all, it's super cliche for this show. second of all, it kinda seems like she's just desperate for SOMEONE at the hospital to like her. i was really looking forward to lexie being the strong/confident grey sister and not be whiny about how her life sucks. and if they're trying to make her seem strong/confident by having casual sex with alex, well, that's just annoying and not original.
i miss izzie and alex! she was the only one to ever put him in his place and they are great together. this george thing won't last, it's stupid.
plus, what was the point of eva/rebecca coming back to just sleep with alex one more time and disappear?
26em1282 — Hahn thinks Cristina slept her way to the top. I don't think she knows Izzie had anything to do with the heart debacle.
27definately not the greatest episode of this season, but it was still good. i don't like dr. hahn that much, but she did have some good lines, like when she asked mark and derek if they were a couple, and "pretty and prettier". and i could see something happening with her and mark. i totally called the alexie sex as soon as he found her in the closet. i think they could have potential. and i liked george and izzie's convo about the surgery, her breakdown, not so much. and i loved how christina was playing therapist with meredith.
28and who is pacey?
Ahh, thanks Buzz! I thought Hahn and Christina bonded a few episodes back...when Hahn was praising her for, well, reminding her of herself. But now I get it.
29trying to answer my own question.
30pacey as in dawson's creek pacey?
is he going to be on next week?
i didn't see the previews.
yeah pacey from dawsons ^
31Thanks, rocknrepublic! Nice pic, by the way
Page6lovers--"trying to answer my own question.
pacey as in dawson's creek pacey?
is he going to be on next week?
i didn't see the previews."
Yep he is set to start in Episode 11 and have a several episode arc (thanks to Buzz for that gem a couple weeks ago)
32LOL no problem brittanybe
33krampalicious said it all....I am so done with this show.
34Team Hahn all the way!
35I'd like to see George in pain more. It bothered me how he cheated on his wife and it seemed like there weren't any consequences. It was nice to see Sloan make him hold that dress for Callie.
Lexie is ridiculous and needs to go. she adds nothing. and now meredith will hate her forever....she does need her own life. go transfer somewhere, and let alex get over ava.
36i really enjoyed this episode okay well i guess i love every episode but this one was really really awesome!
i loved that Meredith said what she said to Derek and made me smile. And i think it meant ALOT to derek that she finally said that. But now she needs to say what said to Cristina to Derek because that was something he should hear too. But thanks Shonda for giving us more hope for merder.
i actually like Dr. Hahn she is kinda a girl version of Burke maybe even more hardcore. lol
The end scene with Derek, Mark, The Cheif and her was funny the Cheif is so cute. Having a guys night and just chillin playing Monopoly lol
Cristina was so funny and this episode i loved when she was begging Iz to switch patients.
oh yeah back to Gizzie im starting to kinda i said kinda like Gizzie they still arent even close to my favourite couple but i think i like them better then Alex and Lexie! What the hell is up with that? Alex likes AVA! AVA! AVA! not LEXIE! come on alex.
grrrr. i wasnt happy about that at all!
but to get off that subject because im getting mad lol i like that Callie got to make george annoyed in this episode she deserves to make him annoyed.
The awake open heart surgeoy thing was so cool and i love how izzie calmed the guy down by making the gallery people birds. That was cute and that guy is really good at reading people.
awhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh i just love greys haha
37i really enjoyed this episode okay well i guess i love every episode but this one was really really awesome!
i loved that Meredith said what she said to Derek and made me smile. And i think it meant ALOT to derek that she finally said that. But now she needs to say what said to Cristina to Derek because that was something he should hear too. But thanks Shonda for giving us more hope for merder.
i actually like Dr. Hahn she is kinda a girl version of Burke maybe even more hardcore. lol
The end scene with Derek, Mark, The Cheif and her was funny the Cheif is so cute. Having a guys night and just chillin playing Monopoly lol
Cristina was so funny and this episode i loved when she was begging Iz to switch patients.
oh yeah back to Gizzie im starting to kinda i said kinda like Gizzie they still arent even close to my favourite couple but i think i like them better then Alex and Lexie! What the hell is up with that? Alex likes AVA! AVA! AVA! not LEXIE! come on alex.
grrrr. i wasnt happy about that at all!
but to get off that subject because im getting mad lol i like that Callie got to make george annoyed in this episode she deserves to make him annoyed.
The awake open heart surgeoy thing was so cool and i love how izzie calmed the guy down by making the gallery people birds. That was cute and that guy is really good at reading people.
awhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh i just love greys haha
38best episode this season so far!
-k did anyone find the part w/ the awake patient getting all panicky really really bothersome and freaky?! i don't know why, there wasn't any blood or anything but it just bothered me and i felt so sorry for the patient
-Hahn, although the portrayal of her as a strong female character is inspiring, she really just bugs me. like that 'gentlemen's evening=racism against blacks'? like what the...how does that even relate haha
-I am all for Alex and Lexie!!! mostly cuz i think Alex is hot, though he should shave his beard NOW
-I loved the heart patient's comparison of the birds w/ the patients. especially the cheif being the blue heron
-and yes buzzsugar, izzie's strange pink top was really distracting and looked like it was made for a 12 year-old...
39Izzie makes me ill. Every week she has to be rescued or rescue someone. It's annoying. I'm over her speeches, and I'm over her winning all the time. And I was cringing and disgusted by her crying to George and by them being in bed together...it's digusting!!!
40Tiabia - You said it! I'm so sick of Izzie. The whole crying bit at the end with George just made me gag. I want to take her and Meredith and shake them both and tell them to get over it.
Why is it that strong women characters have to be portrayed as ball-busters? IMHO - Hahn's character would be much more effective if she were subtle rather than over the top.
I love Callie & I love Sloan. I read (in TV Guide, I think) that Sloan is going to fall in love. I so hope it's with Callie. I also love how her makeup was done in this episode. She looked beautiful and strong.
41Does anyone else think Ava will return pregnant with Alex's child?
42My sister and I have a Grey's date and we talk during comercials and after the show, we both dislike Izzie and Gizzie....that bedroom scene was horrible.....could George get any weaker...he's cringe worthy...I like that Alex takes joy in watching him suffer
I like the Kahn character because now there is someone on the show to dislike...every show needs that stong overbearing character....who is somewhat unattractive
43I love the whole "Does the Chief have any fetishes?" "He doesn't seem like the type to have fetishes"...them trying to guess what a 'gentleman's evening' is was hilarious!
44I like that Izzie has become more competent on the show. It's nice to see her use her head as much as her heart, and among the bunch of female characters, it's nice that someone other than Callie show some strength instead of whining and b*tching all the time.
I like McSteamy and McDreamy as a combo still. And thank goodness for Dr. Hahn entering the picture!
45Loved this episode. My favorite part was the Gizzie scene when she breaks down and starts crying. Being a young female resident in the healthcare field I can so relate with what she feels in that moment!
46I didn't think I was going to like Dr. Hahn, but I loved her! She had me rolling the whole episode. Her "are you two a couple?" and the "pretty and prettier" comments were so awesome. My sides hurt from laughing.
I love how protective Mark is of Callie. I think it is sweet.
When they brought the two girls in with the dress, if I had been Callie I would have got a big pair of scissors and cut it in half. Did anyone else think that? Because it seemed so obvious to me and it seriously annoyed me that no one thought of that. It seemed so ridiculous, but then, I guess Mark couldn't have humiliated George if they had done that.
Meredith is annoying to me and I wish they would cut it out already with her and Derek. Just get them together or break them up. I am so so so so so tired of the love triangles and the back and forth it is becoming distracting an taking away from my enjoyment of the show. I don't fricking care what happens with them any more, just stop with the back and forth. I can't take it anymore.
I'm loving Mark and Derek's friendship, their my favorite couple!
Gizzie is just gross and akward and super annoying. I cringe everytime they speak.
I didn't mind Lexie and Alex. He was totally upfront with her so she knew what to expect I guess. I like both of their characters on the show. Alex especially is a favorite of mine. I love how he just says whatever comes into his head and it is usually totally hilarious to me. So far I really like Lexie too.
47I am holding out hope. So many possibilities!
48I felt like the show was "on cruise control" this week ... nothing spectacular to me.
49I like how strong Dr Hahn seems to be but I truly hope she won't take too much space. I missed Bailey.
Is it me or there something starting again between McSteamy and Callie ? I would not be surprised to see these two in the same bed again before long.
The Gizzie crying scene made me sick ... again, I can't stand this storyline. And it seems to me it get worse every week.
I wonder who between Alex and Lexie, Meredith will blame for having sex together ... I'm pretty sure she will blame one of them ... and I see well Alex telling her it's not her business.
I'm over Meredith with her self-pity crap...
No more Gizzie please!
More Dr. hahn, more Dr. Bailey, more Dr. Sloane...
And i hope Pacey doesn't sleep with Meredith. I'll puke all over if that happens...
And I can't wait until Dr. hahn finds about her pet Izzie and the heart!!!!
50Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.