I've been sifting through the list of 2009 Emmy nominees, and now that I've gotten past my initial reactions of delight (Elisabeth Moss!) and annoyance (still no Friday Night Lights in the major categories, ugh), I'm ready to talk about all these feelings.

- First and foremost: I am so happy for Elisabeth Moss, aka Peggy on Mad Men. I was rooting for any/all of the women on that show, and I'm thrilled that Moss is the one nominated.
- As for the men, it's neat to see Jon Hamm nominated for not just his role as Don Draper but also his guest spot on 30 Rock. Mad Men and 30 Rock were the big winners at last year's Emmys, and now we've had one crossover with Hamm on 30 Rock — I think it would be pretty awesome to see Tina Fey guest star somehow on Mad Men.
- The Emmys' love affair with Mad Men continues in many other categories, including the ones for costumes (naturally), directing, casting and four out of the five nominations for Outstanding Writing for a Drama Series. That's insane! I'm more excited than ever for that durned show to return next month.
- The fifth nomination (and the only one not for Mad Men) in the writing category is for Carlton Cuse and Damon Lindelof's work on the Lost season finale, "The Incident." I couldn't agree more with this nomination, and I find it interesting that this is the one episode in the entire world of dramatic television writing that the Academy deemed on par with the writing on Mad Men
More thoughts if you read more.
- Some surprising snubs: True Blood, The Shield, and Battlestar Galactica all ignored in the major categories. Both The Shield and Battlestar Galactica had good, solid final seasons.
- I have to say, I chuckled a little bit to see Chandra Wilson and Sandra Oh receive some nods for their work on Grey's Anatomy, while Katherine Heigl's name is nowhere to be found. At the same time, I actually do think Heigl was deserving of a nomination this time around.
- Hooray for Damages! The Glenn Close nod was pretty much a given, but now Rose Byrne is also being recognized, along with Ted Danson and — perhaps best of all — William Hurt, whom I think turned in a tremendous and gut-wrenching performance this past season. He made me cry. Cry, I tell you!
- Hurt has some tough competition in that Best Supporting Actor category, as he's joined by John Slattery of Mad Men, Aaron Paul of Breaking Bad, and Michael Emerson of Lost. I feel compelled to root for Emerson the most, but it's a difficult decision.
- As for the Lead Actor and Actress nominees, it's a bit of a snoozefest since the lists are practically the same as last year's. The Lead Actor category is the same as last year's if you sub Simon Baker for James Spader, and the actress one is the same as last year's with Elisabeth Moss added. Are they just afraid to not nominate, say, Mariska Hargitay or Michael C. Hall at this point? Or are all of them really just that good year after year?
- It's Big Edie vs. Little Edie in the Lead Actress for a Miniseries or Movie category!
- Speaking of that category, Chandra Wilson's nomination makes me kinda want to see that Accidental Friendship movie on the Hallmark channel.

Got thoughts on the drama categories?
Source and Grey's photos copyright 2009 ABC, Inc.

Paul & Joe
Mary McDonnell's performance in the last season of Battlestar was absolutely breathtaking. I have not seen better acting anywhere. I know that sounds a bit crazy, but it was astonishingly natural, subtle, brilliantly judged throughout, it took my breath away. The other actors in the category she ISN'T EVEN IN are fine, good solid actresses, but there isn't a single performance that comes close. I'm very disappointed.
1YOu know I gotta admit, I knew that Kathreine Heigl was not going to get nominated this year. I mean don't get me wrong, she did a great job and she was deserving of at least a nomination. But that stupid comment she made last year was well...shall we say ill advised? Too bad though cause I agree, this was her best work on GA. Oh well maybe next time she won't be so...careless about what she says.
2I am not bothering with the Emmy awards this year for the same reason I boycotted last year - they failed to ever nominate The Wire (last year being the last opportunity) and again they snub FNL and all castmembers. Whatever.
3There's not going to be a "next time" for Ms. Highhorse, she's done. She never deserved the nomination, nor the Emmy the first time, and she sure doesn't deserve it now. When she learns to convey correct emotion and not play the same annoying, manipulative characters, then maybe she will deserve it. That won't ever happen anyway though, so no worries.
4Can't believe they overlooked BSG. It was the best writing on tv for years plus some of the best performances. Stupid sci fi prejudice.
5Do you even watch Dexter? If you did, you'd realize why Michael C. Hall has been nominated two years in a row. Dexter has been on for three seasons, and he wasn't nominated the first season, so this is only his second nomination for Dexter. His amazing work is why he is nominated, not because anyone is afraid not to. Tony Shaloub has been nominated for Monk for 4 or 5 times in a row, so maybe pick on him instead.
6She's done? Yeah tell that to the creatoers of GA who signed her on for next year as well as the two projects she has going on for the next year as well. Don't forget to give your two cents to the people who nominated her in 07 and to the people who VOTED for her that year. Like her or not, she had garnered a LOT of positive feedback with her performance that year and this year now. And regardless of what a few ill minded pseudo witty pompous haters have to say, that still doesn’t change the fact that she She was on a ton of people's wish list this year when it came to the nods.
7I'm glad that stuck up Heigl didn't get nominated.
8Love Mad Men!
9I think the Emmy should go to Wiliam Hurt. The other actors are all great but Hurt absolutely elevated the second season of Damages in a way the others can't compare to. His bumbling, King Lear-esque accidental bad guy in season 2 was such a brilliant foil to Dansen's sleazy snake oil salesman in season 1.
10Oh, and I totally agree every character on Dexter deserves a hundred Emmys each. Best show in history, hands down.
11Surprised BSG was snubbed, the entire last season was amazing, and the season finale... beyond anything I could've imagined. Also surprised Karev wasn't nominated, I thought he did a great job, really showed off his skills.
12What about the Friday Night Lights snubs? Some of the best acting on television, not to mention a wonderful overall show. Disappointing.
13Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.