Part of the fun of watching reality TV is watching the judges bicker, tease each other, and occasionally fall all over themselves with praise for a contestant. Some shows pick their judges at the start of the show and never waver; others add guest judges into the mix; still others (say, American Idol) add new full-time judges to shake things up. Tell me: Which reality show has your favorite judging panel overall?
Photos courtesy of Fox, NBC, Bravo, MTV, and ABC
Vanessa Bruno
Robe Di Firenze
Start London
I love Nigel on SYTYCD.
1It comes down to Top Chef and Project Runway for me. I voted Top Chef, because I don't know exactly what's going to happen with PR on its new network.
2SYTYCD judging panel s the best; they're specific in their criticism and in their praise. Nigel is great.
3Project Runway, even though I detest Nina Garcia. Heidi Klum & Michael Kors are hilarious though.
4Project Runway.
5I know Mary Murphy annoys a lot of people- but I love her and her screams! Linda McP ---> So true about their critiques!
6I think most of them are great for different reasons, but I went with Top Chef.
7I like the crazy lady in the picture, bottom left, my son and I laugh the whole time we have her on. She's nuts!
8SYTYCD judge panel are experts in their fields, and they appreciate people who have a passion for dance even if they need to work on. Other judges (ANTM) just try to insult you or be funny.
9SYTYCD, especially Nigel & Mary... the judges on the Canadian version are great too, we get Jean Marc Généreux full time
I love him!
10Top Chef!!
11Oh god, when it comes to judging, I always mute when Mary Murphy is speaking.
12oh man, this was hard. I had to go with Top Chef...as long as Toby Young isn't on panel. I wish Anthony Bourdain or Ted Allen were regular judges. ABDC and SYTYCD's judges come in next.
13I went with Project Runway, but I also like the judges on SYTYCD and Top Chef.
14i picked PR but i love TC too
15I had to pick Project Runway. I love that they always have a guest judge, and I love all three regular judges too.
16SYTYCD hands down. i love nigel. mary is alright, & i love guest judges especially Lil C
17Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.