I've been curious about the Farrelly Brothers' Three Stooges project for a while now, and "curious" is also the word I'd use to describe today's casting news. Sean Penn is, as rumored, on board to play Larry, and Jim Carrey has entered negotiations to play Curly. And while nobody's officially claimed the role of Moe, The Hollywood Reporter says Benicio del Toro has been named as a possibility.

So, let's take a look at these three. Could they be funny together? With the exception of Carrey, none of them is particularly known for being funny solo, but maybe there's a hidden world of pratfalls and "nyuk-nyuk"s buried deep inside of them. Also of note, this tidbit about the project itself:
Originally constructed as four separate shorts, the feature screenplay has since been streamlined into a single narrative. Included in the story line is an opening that shows the Stooges as kids in an orphanage, a device that will require some Benjamin Button-style visual trickery to place the adult actors' heads on child actors' bodies.
So, it seems we've got a lot to talk about. How do these three potential Stooges-to-be stack up to your recast picks (I can't believe they wouldn't/couldn't get John C. Reilly)? And how are you feeling about the project itself at this point?

















Birkenstock
Ajc
Betty Jackson
I cannot imagine Benicio Del Toro playing any of the Stooges.
1I can't see this at all.
2Is this a bio-pic or just a comedy in the style of the Three Stooges?
3a comedy in the style of the Three Stooges
4i'll take benicio any way i can get him
yum
5well i wonder if they are going to take another spin on the stooges and make it less obviously funny - that could be why the casting choices are being made. we'll just have to see - i'm not sure that i'm into this one just yet.
6I love the original Three Stooges and I feel like, no matter how well it's done, this just isn't going to hold a candle to the original.
7oh this'll be good
8This could be interesting...
9I can see it. It would be neat if it's them acting on the show and hating each other backstage. I can see that.
10i'll take benicio any way i can get him
11yum
I second that!
Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.