Before this month's "Grey's Anatomy" finale, we in the Sugar office were debating whether "Grey's" jumped the shark this season with the not-wedding, the trip to heaven, the multiple parental deaths, etc. It got me thinking about all of the ridiculous things that have happened on that show since the start. What's your pick for the most insane "Grey's" plot twist of all time?
Photo copyright 2007 ABC, Inc.
Together
Dwell
Marc Jacobs
*lol* so many good ones..I voted for the LVAD cutting one, but they are all ridiculous.
1Meredith drowning....what were they thinking???
2I forgot about the secret brain surgery - yeah, that was pretty bizarre.
3no joke- the drowning thing was so friggin cheesy... kill off meredith is what i say.
4I still love this show despite the crazy things that happen on it! I voted for Callie living in the basement because seriously? The girl has all this money and sleeps in the hospital basement?? I've always thought she was a little crazy.
5I voted for Meredith drowning. Izzie cutting the LVAD wire was pretty ridiculous too.
6the whole show is silly. why do people watch this tripe?
7I thought Cali living the the hospital...her parents are freaking loaded.
8All so funny- I never watched the first two seasons much so now I am so intrigued- secret brain surgery, syphillis???? I guess I should go back and watch just for laughs, no
9Wow, I had forgotten that there were so many! Voted for Mere's near-death. Izzie's bone marrow w/her daughter and how fast that happened was pretty unrealistic too.
10You need an all of the above button. One of the MANY things I find hard to believe is that these interns are so buddy buddy with the chief or hooking up with top surgeons... where are the other interns? Is this program only for those 5 (5 right?)
11I think the guy who came in and had that mass pushing on his frontal lobe, causing everything he thought to come out of his mouth had to be the most ridiculous! It was entertaining though. I love Grey's!!!
12Meredith's "death" was the absolute nadir. And the worst part of that sadly predictable storyline was when Doc the dog jumped up on her deathbed in heaven. Denny, Dylan and Doc ... oh my!
13I was going for the whole Callie in the basement ordeal. But who cares, I love Grey's Anatomy!
14other- how about Meredith's step mom dieing of hiccups?
15it was hard to pick only one!
16The Gizzy thing is just plain craziness.
17Although Meredith in hosital heaven was insane as well.
...the entire show is hell bent on putting them in crazy situations and ruining the characters' happiness now.
Is it so wrong for (at least) one person on the show to not be "dark and twisty"?
Meredith drowning!!! That was so stupid...
18i didn't see the episode when Meredith drowning - sound good to me. but i voted for Izzie and gorge are sleeping together - sound very stupid to me.
19Meredith dying than coming back to life. LAME! How long was she supposed to be under water for anyway??
20definitely meredith drowning and "dying". shoulda just killed her off. however, this whole show has gone downhill after the first season IMO
21i think it was in season 2, i haven't been an avid follower of grey's but natalie cole with a fork stuck in her neck?!
22a lot of these were ridiculous. it was hard to choose.
23Id have to pick a few of the above. Def LVAD, heart surgery in an elevator, clinic opening in 8 days, Mere being fine after drowning, etc.
24i dont watch this show.
25I used to love this show, but it's just gotten a little crazy with the story lines. And to leave us with a season finale where every major character was miserable? What's that about?
26the only part of this show i've seen had to do with a kid being brought in on an ambulance with a huge tree branch through his chest. and guess what, he was fine!
27oh, and those doctors sure are slutty.
wtf kind of hospital is that?
Other: Husband leaves wife because she cheated on him, wife comes to WA to find him, ex-best friend/guy she cheated with comes out and they all work together without ripping each other's faces off.
I love Grey's, but you have to look far beyond real life and common sense to be able to enjoy it.
28ALL OF THE ABOVE!
29I've been really loyal to the show, but I'm saying it now: the Lexie Grey thing might do me in. If Derek even contemplates dating her, I will stop watching. Shark definitely jumped with the ferry incident. The show might not recover.
30the worst was when the decsion maker on who would be chief of surgery had a fish in his penis cause he peed in the river. SERIOUSLY?! WHERE DO THEY COME UP WITH THIS!?
31and although all of these are ridiculous i must say i still love the show, although annyoing. grey's still has a place in my heart =P
although it is ALL ridiculous but the more personal storylines lines are crazy compared to the medical conditions because they are based on at least some truth. i love this show! i just wonder if all this in the long run will screw it up.
32this show is really stupid sometimes =p. but i love my patrick dempsey.
33They are all ridiculous, but that's what makes the show addicting!!!
34How about Izzie knitting an entire sweater in ONE DAY and then still having time to WEAR IT for a few hours before giving it to Denny? Oh, and help knit Meredith some pieces of her sweater, too.
35All of the above. Except for Cristina getting left at the altar. We all knew that was coming. It was the perfect get-Isiah Washington-off-the-show-but-don't-kill-him-incase-we-need-a-guest-appearance move.
36What about Izzie performing surgery on a deer outside the hospital so the little boy wouldn't feel bad?
37shafiii- that fish in the penis storyline actually is possible...here's what dr. oz has to say about it: http://www2.oprah.com/health/oz/oz_20070521_350_109.jhtml
38Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.