On this week's Grey's Anatomy, lots of (mostly metaphorical) ghosts start floating around Seattle Grace. There's the ghost of Izzie's relationship with Denny, possibly preparing to start haunting all of Seattle Grace as well. There's the ghost of Denny himself, not letting Izzie go. There's the ghost of Meredith's mother, still present in those journals. And that's just the beginning, so to talk about it, just read more.
When this episode ended, I felt angry. Not because it hadn't been good, but because that's the way they chose to say goodbye to Brooke Smith's Erica Hahn: by giving her the kind of compelling medical story that she should have had all along. Exploring Izzie's role in Denny's death from the perspective of Hahn and the patient who should have had Denny's heart is a great story, and a necessary one. It always seemed odd that Izzie's suspension was the only punishment. Hahn wants more, and she plans to stir up trouble by reporting the deeds to UNOS. That fight with Callie — with Hahn saying this is a matter with clear right and wrong, and Callie arguing that without being in that room with Denny, there's no way to know — is the last we'll see of Hahn, right when her best story was starting. I wonder how they'll explain her departure, because the Hahn we know would never flee from a little fight like that. She'd embrace it.
Without even knowing how Hahn plans to take her down, Izzie feels haunted all episode, because the person who should have had Denny's heart is in Denny's old room and she keeps seeing Denny just . . . sitting there. It nearly means she can't talk her patient through surgery, and it definitely wreaks havoc with her mind (to Meredith: "When your dead mommy teaches you things, do you see her?"). I was actually getting a little tired of Ghost Denny — until the end, when Izzie tells him to leave, he's replaced in her view by Alex, and then Denny pops up elsewhere, just trying to make sure she's really OK.

Meanwhile, the story that really almost made me lose it was Derek and Bailey operating on the woman with the perfect marriage. Despite what they'd talked about before, the man can't let his Rosie go. And then Bailey can't, either, because that would be like killing the conception she still has of true love. Finally, Derek steps in — he who knows all too well that marriage isn't perfect — to let Rosie die the way she'd wished.
In other news:
- I love Owen Hunt. I love that we have a character who can say that these interns are immature, rude, too preoccupied with their personal lives, and not prepared to be doctors. I love that Cristina manages to shake up his conceptions of her by revealing the very personal story about her father that led her into medicine. Love!
- The Chief and the surgery robot is obvious comic relief, but man, did I love that it's George O'Malley who gets the worst of it.
- Speaking of comic relief, Mark hitting on Cristina Yang? Is there a worse potential pairing in the history of Grey's? So many great lines, including Cristina's shocked giggles and everything related to "single-malt Scotch."
- The weird underground surgical intern IV practice circle makes me uncomfortable, but so did Lexie stealing the cadavers. It's a good excuse for some speechifying from Bailey, in any case.
Are you on Hahn's side or Callie's? Are you still moved by the appearance of Denny? And can you think of a worse pairing than Mark and Cristina? Discuss!
Photos copyright 2008 ABC

















Claudio Merazzi
1881 Cerruti Blue
J Brand
I smiled a huge smile Every single moment Denny was on that screen. Cried too. at that and the older couple? heartbreaking!
I know many doctors, and they all said they practiced on eachother when they were interns.
I laughed my arse off at the robot, and at georges ability to keep working on it even when others would have stopped, and when Hunt came in to talk to it/chief. awesome.
1Mark and Cristina made me laugh. She was completely oblivious. I think he needed that little experience.
And I wanted to CHEER when McArmy chewed them out. I get so tired of them treating the patients like meat. I hope he keeps standing up to them.
I thought the Hahn and Callie thing ended weird. It seemed...unnatural. I didn't see it coming (excluding the news reports
) and something about the way it was left hanging was completely unsatisfying as a viewer. It
didn't even really seem like she was leaving, just that they had a fight. And I thought her attack on Callie's sexuality was out of line.
I'm glad Mer is embracing dead mommy but I don't want her relationship with Derek to suffer for it. She seems like she has a hard time prioritizing.
And OMG the old couple. I cried. He was so sweet. And they just loved each other so much. I hope Bailey and Tucker can work it out.
2I can't help but smile when Jeffrey Dean Morgan is on screen. He's so gorgeous and such a man! Ohhh baby!
As much as I don't really like Alex and I think Justin Chambers is really ugly, he and Izzie are really cute together.
The married couple made me bawl! I'm not even kidding. Ever since I got married, I can't watch stuff like that because it makes me really depressed. So there I am watching it on my laptop next to my husband sleeping and I'm bawling and holding on to him. It was awful.
I'm on Callie's side just because I've never ever liked Hahn.
George and the robot made me LOL but it seemed a little mean to see Chief laughing like that.
3amloveaffair I am so glad you said that. I didn't start until I got married either! And now any time a husband or wife dies I SOB thinking of what I would do without my husband. Then I make him promise repeatedly to never leave me. Glad to know I'm not alone
4Me too! I thought I was such a sap but I can't help it! and I'm only 20 and he's 25 so hopefully we're not going to die any time soon!
I agree with you, I think Hahn questioning Callie's sexuality was out of line too because last time we saw them as a couple everything was fine.
5I love McBadass (Owen Hunt)! I love how he called them all out on being immature. He has a little thing for Christina
! He is my favorite character!
The robot and George was hilarious! And Sloan flirting with Christina - they are an interesting pair. I love how frustrated he got but Christina just laughed.
I didn't care for Izzie's scenes. It's getting annoying.
And I'm totally on Callie's side, but how Hahn left is such a shame. They should give more of a better ending for her.
6I loved mark trying to hit on christina - "this doesn't happen to me!"
I also liked dr hunt calling them all on their shenanigans! although I always think of kevin mckidd as tommy from trainspotting
and I was furious with the way they ended callie and hahn as well, I would like to see how they explain it next week because it would be out of character for a strong woman like hahn to just disappear. they will probably say she resigned after finding out about izzie and denny. but they spent all this time showing how much she cares about callie, and now she's just going to walk away?
7I'll agree that it was an odd send off, but I can't say I'm sad to see Hahn go. I never liked her character, and I thought her storyline with Callie was way too contrived. There was no chemistry, especially when it was so often paired with Callie's obvious chemistry with McSteamy.
Denny's presence and Ed and Rosie had me going. I really needed that good cry. This is what used to make Grey's so good, so maybe they're onto something here again! That would be awesome, to feel like it was the Grey's of old again. Keep it up!
8I never liked Erica but that's just stupid the way they let her go. Why couldn't they just end the relationship between her and Callie? There's definitely something fishy about it.
9The older couple seriously made me cry. And Owen Hunt made me swoon a little with his "single malt scotch" line. I didn't think Yang would know the patient's name- I was glad to know that under the tough exterior she really does care. The story about her dad was really sad.
Interesting to see how the reporting to UNOS plays out. Kind of hope it spells an Izzie departure- she is not my favorite character.
10Okay, first of all, the Hahn thing was ridiculous. That was the worst send-off ever. Not only did she come off b*tchy, but nothing is resolved at all! Also, you can kind of be a lesbian. Ever heard of bisexual?
Anyways, not that I got that off my chest, ghost Denny was bugging me too. I kept wanting to yell at Izzie to blink, or concentrate, or something before her patient failed another ablation. Plus, I really like her and Alex together, so I want them to do well.
Other random stuff: The older couple was so heartbreaking. Seeing things like that always make me think of how horrible it would be to be the one left behind. And Owen Hunt? I don't how I feel about him yet. Oh, and who else thinks that someone's going to get hurt playing doctor with the interns?
11well i think that the whole callie and hahn thing is really interesting. i think that hahn has this thing in her mind that ALL things are black and white and callie is more realistic about it all. you knew that was going to happen and i'm glad that callie got to say her piece.
i think that it's interesting how christina and hunt's relationship is developing. she proved him wrong in a nice way - talking about why she went into medicine, proving that she did know the patient's name and then walking away. at least we know that hunt thinks that she's truly a 'single malt scotch'.
i had to laugh sooo hard at the mark/christina thing. that was truly funny!
12tls I agree. I don't really think I like Hunt.
13I really enjoyed this episode.
The scene with old couple had me crying too.
The Mark/Cristina 'thing' this episode was hilarious and lead perfectly into the scene with Hunt and Cristina at the end... which I really like.
Love that they keep finding way to bring Denny back.
I never liked Haun so I'm not sad to see her go, although I agree it was a pretty random departure and I'm curious to see how they plan on cleaning up her storylines.
I hated the part about the IV practice circle and Lexie stealing the cadavers.
14I don't care what the status of those bodies were, Lexie was WAY in the wrong taking them and think it should have been handled totally different by Bailey.
The sweet couple made me cry too. I just sat on the couch and sobbed like a baby. I thought the episode was really great! I can't wait for next week.
15amloveaffair: I shared an elevator with Justin Chambers once and honestly, he's way better looking in person. I don't care for his character of Alex but yeah...he's better looking and is more statuesque in person.
I ♥ Hunt. He is like a breath of fresh air. I loved when Cristina shared the story of how her dad died with him. She's opening up to him...it's wonderful. They're the only two redeeming characters on the show.
16Hahn's exit was truly unsatisfying. Like you, Buzz, I was angry with the way this all ended. Overall, though, I think this was one of the better episodes this season. Bailey, as always, was awesome. And like most everyone else, I cried when Rosie died. What a beautiful relationship those two had. thanks for the great recap!
17I LOVED when Mark was hitting on Cristina. It was so funny how she just didn't realize it every time, and then when he told her, and she laughed! Oh MAN, that was awesome.
And George with the robot and the Chief talking through it? OMG! So funny! I liked this episode a lot.
18I liked this episode. I think that this episode was strong as far as acting goes. I was really disappointed how things went down with Hahn but I thought she was awesome! Sara's (Kallie) teeth are SO white I was like holy crap at that end part.
Hunt was weird this week since he was SO hardcore last week and this week he was all sensitive about the guy that Christina and Alex were trying to help first. It was weird I thought.
19I did like this episode and I do like Denny, but I hope it's the last time they show him. I'm sick of him showing up randomly, he's dead!!!!! Let's let it go now.
I'm glad Hahn is gone and the chief told her off. She seems really unstable..and a b*tch.
The rest was good though.
20STOP BRINGING DENNY BACK SHONDA!!! My heart cannot take it, it's like I have to say goodbye to him over & over again, it's not nice. BUT I love JDM so I guess the tears will just have to continue as long as his hotness keeps appearing. I love JDM but I hate seeing Denny over & over again knowing that he's gone and him & Izzie will never get married or kiss again or anything
I loved that Alex was there in that end scene!
Yang/Hunt FTW!!!!! Is that the only personal story Yang has EVER told? And she told Owen???
God I love Owen, he is becoming my favourite character already, he acts all tough & angry but then he will crack & you can see the tears.
Mark hitting on Cristina has to be the FUNNIEST thing ever!!!!!
The Chief and that dummy was hilarious, poor Georgie!!!!!
21I forgot to mention the Bailey/McDreamy storyline. It was just so so so sad, I'm still upset about it now. What a tragic love story. When the guy walked out of the hospital by himself, I broke down. He never got to say "Hello" again
22the old couple made me CRY LIKE A BABY! no joke.. i just couldn't hold back the tears!!!!
i too hate hahn's character.. she infuriates me! i'm sort of glad to see her go, but that ending was much too abrupt. i also loved the scene between yang & hunt in the little room. i love christina's character and sandra oh is an amazing actress!
23the old couple made me CRY LIKE A BABY! no joke.. i just couldn't hold back the tears!!!!
i too hate hahn's character.. she infuriates me! i'm sort of glad to see her go, but that ending was much too abrupt. i also loved the scene between yang & hunt in the little room. i love christina's character and sandra oh is an amazing actress!
24It's a huge testament to what Grey's used to be that they created a character that the mere site of can make me tear up. I cried like a baby at the end of Grey's last night when Denny asked if Izzy was really OK. I was really looking forward to last night's episode and it didn't disappoint. I really think the show is starting to look up.
25If that is how they ended it with Hahn, it is terribly dissapointing.
My favorite line "I"m bleeding out!" from the robot/the Chief!
The old couple story was so sad and sweet!
Maybe I'm the only one, but how many times are they going to bring back Dead Denny? I'm just not feeling that storyline anymore.
I can't wait for a real McArmy/Christina hookup
26I loved that old couple. And the way Bailey said "I know YOU can't" I about lost it. That was the most touching moment of the whole episode for me.
The second most was Izzie telling Denny to leave her alone. I can imagine the turmoil her character was dealing with, and that had to be hard, but she's right! It's time for her to move on. Denny can be her "guardian angel" but she can live without "him" now.
I felt for her during the surgery. Again, that had to be SO difficult for her. I think though it was exactly what needed to happen for her to move on.
BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO TO HAHN! I'm glad she's gone. I didn't like her OR her character and I hope they find another woman for Callie who is MUCH more worthy of her. Callie's character is a funny, quirky, sensitive girl that needs to be with someone KIND of soft, but that will ground her. Hahn was just a mean and nasty b***h in my opinion and I didn't like her from day one. (Probably because she wanted to let Denny die LOL)
I am curious though how they're going to explain her sudden disappearance since she didn't tell Callie "I'm leaving this hospital if that's how it's run" or anything along those lines (unless I missed it) so they WILL have to give an explanation. I do agree though that this story had to happen. Had Izzie done any of that in a REAL hospital, it would have been the end of her medical career, no matter how much her superiors liked her. She couldn't have been saved from it. I'm going to be extremely interested to see how that pans out.
I love Mer's "My Dead Mommy taught me" LOL I was about dying when Izzie asked if she sees her. hehehe
Overall, I thought the acting was superb and the writing was outstanding. It was everything I've come to expect from Grey's (With the exception of the hahn thing)
27I loved that they brought Denny back...and I think the new doc is soooo AMAZING
28McArmy? I love that nickname AND him! Can't wait to see him and Bailey tie up about something!
29Oh Grey's how i love thee this season.
First off I loooooved the robot. At first I couldn't figure out how it came coming out with such spot on responses and then to see the chief and the tech! It was classic. I also loved George cuz he kept going no matter what...and that's the kinda awesome doc he is going to make:)
I thought the basement IV grp was weird but I used to work with nurses and they told me they practiced on each other in school. So there u have it.
Sloan--I love him. And i loved seeing him get shut down and Christina walking away laughing.
Owen-Geez i cant get enough of this man. Just when I am getting irritated that he is being too harsh he has a moment of vulnerability and I just melt completely. And he sooooo has a thing for christina--a major thing! cant wait til he makes his next move. Hope he isnt too traumatized from Iraq so I can see him get it on with Yang ASAP.
The old couple--perfect love and when he let go and let bailey do the chest pumping...god we should all be so lucky to have someone love us as much
Oh God and Denny. I don't think I ever got over his death b.c I was bawling by the end of the episode. Every time he came up on last night's episode all these scenes of him and Izzie flashed through my head and the scenes of her in her beautiful dress going to see him b4 he died...I was destroyed when Shonda killed him (You hear that Shonda!). Like bawling like it was my love who died. And to see him again last night was hard but therapeutic. I still cried but it was a crying of letting him go. (Yes i realize this is a fictional show...but some things hit very close to home to me...if u love someone deeply u prob understand)
I did think it was good for Izzie to be confronted with the other heart patient. she needs to confront her actions and the consequences so she can heal.
Cant wait til next week!
30Oh and I'm glad Hahn is gone. Never liked her. Thought she was cold and never fit in with the rest of the gang. However I do wish her departure had been handled in a better way. Don't know in what way since I am not a writer but I thought it was too hasty of an exit. Maybe it will play out better in the weeks to come. I loooove Callie and I just think that Hahn is not the right person for such a sweet sensitive (yet very competent) and bold character.
31I forgot- I also loved the scene with McDreamy and Sloan in the elevator when he goes- "I'm not your stud horse" and McDreamy goes "You slept with my wife." Sloan- "Yeah... I'll do it." That made me laugh pretty hard. I'm really glad they are friends again.
32Really Indielove? He seems like he'd be a sweet guy but sometimes he just makes me gag, sometimes he is cute though.
33You know, I liked Denny when he was alive on the show and all, but I'm with the others on here who want that storyline left alone. C'mon writers, let's move on now. It's gotten to the point where his appearance just doesn't do anything for me anymore.
34i miss Denny but being a ghost is kinda annoying to me
, have not seen the episode
yet..............
35i was sobbing during the scene with the old guy and his rosie.
i want that kind of
relationship. denny...i love denny..i would love a man like denny...sorry rambling. this episode was interesting. the story with christina and dr. hunt excites me and i can't wait to see
where it goes. erica hahn's story ended far too quickly and needs to be explained more....izzy and alex..izzie and denny...death and love what mix. i seriously was sobbing this whole show. i
don't know if i was just pms'ing or because i'm having my own issues with my marriage and love but it all really hit very close to home. i love this show. denny ducette or marc sloan can
haunt me any time....
36I seriously sobbed during the older couple storyline. That stuff just tears me up. Denny and Izzie always make me cry. She kinda annoys me sometimes, but their romance was just...wow.
37Loved this episode, statred crying at the older couple story.i loved sEeing denny again and mark hitting on christina was hilarious. I also like the new doctor, i still want him and christina together.
38McArmy is all handsome but I wonder if McArmy will suffer from PTSD, he kinda seems like he has some major issues from Iraq, though who wouldn't.
Hate, Hahn, and glad she's gone, but terrible send off.
And as much as I don't really like Izzie, or the actress who plays her, I just couldn't see the show without her. Can't see the show without any of the main characters, so I hope the organ stealing/UNOS thing doesn't really go anywhere.
And Denny... one word awww. Though the storyline is overused sometimes, every time he shows up I can't help but swoon.
Mark flirting with Cristina and the George/Robot/Chief surgery thing, hilarious.
The gang seem to all be bad residents. They are still acting like interns. Forgetting that they have people that they have to teach. Always worrying about getting time in the OR. Bailey never forgot she was teaching them, heck she still does it now, and they aren't her interns anymore. Hopefully they'll get their heads out of the asses soon. And those poor interns are going to get themselves into trouble I thinks.
But great episode, this season is so much better than last season, and some of the season before.
39This was such an incredible episode. I teared up at several intervals and believe me I only cry if it's GOOD. I loved the old married couple- they were so sad and I felt so bad for the husband and I hate Shepard a little bit for stopping. Denny and Izzie are so sad- I'm starting to like her a little more again and she really showed her skills again this episode. I loved that opening scene when Alex puts his arm around her- they're so incredible together and he's so hot. Cristina's story about her dad was so sad, and I was actually quite shocked she knew the patient's name. I love her though...still miss Burke.
I agree with the above in terms of the resident's ability to teach. They are truly horrible. They managed to have the best resident and have not passed on those skills at all! I feel so bad for the interns, once they finally found cadavers to work on they were stolen away and then scolded by Bailey!
40My two cents on this episode.....McArmy...he is my new fav member of staff at SGH!!! He totally rocks...he is a no nonsense kinda guy and I think this is what the show needed cause,..tbh, Bailey was getting a little soft..just in my opinion
Denny has got to stop popping up...he is hot and really good to look at and I'm glad the whole drama with Izzy got dragged out in the open once more but Denny himself appearing and disappearing has to end.....
ok on to why I'm happy that the whole Denny drama got out...Erica Hahn...I'm sad to see her go because of her treats towards the hospital and Izzy..I really wanted to see where it would go....how could she leave after saying all of that...it just doesn't add up.. on the other hand, I'm not too sad to see her go because now Callie and McSteamy can get back to the on-call room....they have chemistry...
Hilarious parts...McSteamy hitting on Cristina....his bewildered looks to her giggles was just fantastic....George and the robot...badass.."I'm bleeding out"....and all the cracks at Alex and his bedside manner...it was the chiefs' time to have some fun...McDreamy and McSteamy - Operation "Sleep with Cristina"...Not the best idea Derek has had...
And the old couple was heartbreaking...their story about saying Goodbye before surgeries and then Hello when she wakes up...made me cry...its so sweet...Hurt when they didn't get to say Hello again...and his determination to get her to wake up...so sad..
Can't wait for the next episode....
41Loved Major Hottie and Cristina's little talk at the end...watched it at least 5 times! I am just loving their storyline. Good stuff. Also, George vs the dummy was hilarious!
42yep old couple made me cry.
loved mark hitting on christina- hysterical. especially when he finally told her and she just laughed in his face.
so funny when hunt went in and talked to the dummy.. or chief lol and george caught on.
hunt is growing on me a little- i liked the moment with christina and i'm glad she knew the patients name and shut him up- good for her.
didn't like hahn but didn't like the ending. that was finally a good story line for her. and if they wanted to break her and callie up it was a good way to do it- let this issue come between them- but at least give it a chance to- don't just write her off that way!
i do like callie and mark's chemistry though. i watched two episodes in a row this week on my dvr so i can't remember which one it is when she invites him to the bar- maybe the other one- but i like their friendship.
43Great episode! I cried several times...whenever Denny popped up on screen, and when the old lady died. It was so sad to watch her husband try to resucitate her
Derek's plan to get Cristina laid was stupid, but her reactions to Mark were funny. I love her chemistry with Owen Hunt, and it was nice that she really opened up to him about why she got into medicine.
I didn't like Hahn, but the way that she left the show was terrible. I hope Callie will be able to find someone better though.
44My favorite quote from the entire episode was when Izzie said "It's like a bouquet....of corpses!" LOL.
45Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.