Last night on So You Think You Can Dance, we learned what inspired each of the contestants to become a dancer, and my personal favorite story was Will's. When he talked about seeing Patrick Swayze's moves in Dirty Dancing for the first time and wanting to do that too, I could totally relate! The difference between us, though, is that Will went on to be discovered by Debbie Allen, and I went on to . . . recap SYTYCD.

There was hardly an unpleasant word spoken last night (save for the ones after Comfort and Mark's second dance, but more on that later), as all the dancers trotted out their A-game for routine after routine. I did have to cringe, though, when Mary tried to start one of her feedback segments with a bit about finding "Ashton" because she thought she'd been "punked." Oof. that just fell pretty flat. I love Mary when she's sharing actual dance feedback and insight. I just wish she'd leave the comedy to the experts.
But enough about that. Let's chat about who looked adorable trying his hand at hip hop, the best dance of the night, the dancers in danger, and who Nigel thinks has the biggest "bum" in the competition! To see my thoughts, read more.
There was one routine I enjoyed so much I hit rewind and watched it twice: the first dance from Katee and Twitch. That was hands-down the most fun of the night, and I loved the story that went along with it. Plus, Katee was a little Winehouse-esque with the beehive and wing-tipped eyes. Both dancers should feel plenty safe tonight.
Coming in a close second place for me behind Twitch and Katee's contemporary dance was Courtney and Will's samba. On the shallow side, seeing Will move his hips like that was just so hot. They also blew the judges away with their slowed-down hip hop routine to an Alicia Keys song, and Will turned in a truly memorable and amazing solo. I loved that he did something different with that James Brown impersonation — it was definitely unexpected and was the kind of thing that viewers (and voters!) remember.
Joshua and Chelsie are really memorable in the chemistry department. Their personalities not only shine through on the dance floor but they're also the only two whose studio segments I remember clearly. They make a great team, and they're probably safe. Plus Nigel couldn't help but point out Josh's booty size, which can't hurt.
Comfort was pretty lucky to draw hip hop again, and her routine with Mark was entertaining. Mark was pretty cute trying to keep up, and he definitely held his own on stage. Comfort got smacked down a little, though, when Nigel told her she needs choreography because her solo was weak and unfocused. Things got worse for the pair when the judges weighed in on their foxtrot, with Nigel calling it "amateurish" and Mary calling one move the worst she'd ever seen. The two of them ought to be worried.
So what do you think? Has Comfort's luck finally run out, or do you think she has yet another life in this competition? Which pair was your favorite last night? And do you remember any other solo other than Will's?
Photos courtesy of Fox

















Golden Goose
StyleBop
Giuseppe Zanotti
I think we shall definitely be seeing the last of Comfort, and finally put an end to bad jokes about her name. (Which aren't always puns, btw, Comfort.)
1Tonight was amazing. Almost every dance was fabulous. I really came around to Twitch tonight. I think he out-shined Katee, and proved he deserves a top guy spot. He really is incredibly versatile as well as amazing at his main style. Will, Josh and Twitch need to be the top three guys.
I really liked Courtney and Will together, cool pairing! I'd like to see Will do a harder hip hop, a crump routine would be interesting. Courtney always nails her solos I've come to notice. Whereas Katee's solos really annoy me, something about her hands...I know she's technically strong, but she is not doing it for me and I would not be sad to see her go (after Comfort).
2it's still so interesting to me that Katee gets the types of routines that she does. granted she's an OUTSTANDING dancer - but can we count how many broadway or contemporary routines that she's done? she lucks out since those are typically the crowd pleasers.
i think that it's really getting down to the nitty gritty and it's going to be hard to see who stays and who goes for the remainder of the season. i feel like we've all gotten attached to the dancers, but i certainly have my favorites.
3Mark & Comfort are out (hopefully). I love Mark, I think he's such a character, but out of the four boys left, he is my least favorite. I too love the Katee/Twitch pairing..loved both of their numbers! I think Katee is the best performer, she really understands the characters she is asked to portray and knows how to embody them in her facial and body movement.
I think a lot of people compare Will to last season's Danny..bothe are the strongest technical dancers of their season..but the difference is that Will knows that people want to see some personality come through the dancing as well. Coming out and doing that great James Brown impersonation is a great way to let America know that he's not just a run-of-the-mill contemporary dancer, but he's a good perfomer as well. Nigel noted that in the past 2 seasons, the final 2 was a strong technical dancer and a great performer and the performer always won.
4Also...is anyone else thinking that gesture everyone's doing this season (the hand touching the shoulder) is getting a little played out? Where did that come from anyways? I know it was from earlier this season, but I don't remember...help?
5sumbum, its 4 fingers to the shoulder as in "4 Real" . . . meaning its season 4 of the show
6I think Comfort is totally out. But I loved so many of the dances last night!
7I was soooo bummed. I had tickets to Wednesday's show. They always overbook them to have a full audience at all times and I was 20 people short of getting in. So, of course, it was the best show of the season that I missed! Well, that and I stood in line for 2 hours just to have to watch it on TV
I love so many of the people. It's going to be hard to see people go at this point. Minus Comfort- she just isn't up to the same level as everyone else.
8I think Comfort and Mark will be out tonight. Comfort for the reasons everyone has mentioned and Mark because without Chelsie I don't think it's connecting with the audience as well.
If I had to pick a top 4 right now it'd be Chelsie, Twitch, Will and Courtney.
9First let me say that Comfort is my least favorite in the competition as was Jessica, while Joshua is one of my favorites. That said, the judges are very, very biased this season. It was so clear last night!
They praised Joshua and Chelsie for their disco routine, which was not good at all, (my opinion). And Comfort and Mark who I thought did a pretty good job, (definitely as good as Joshua and Chelsie's Disco number),they put down. Even the last judge (don't know her name) couldn't say anything good about the disco number, she said they captured the spirit of the dance!
Ok, I'm stepping off of my soapbox now!
10My favorite last night was Twitch and Katie's Contempo routine. Was anyone else surprised at the kiss, I couldn't even watch it!
ooooohhhh I just loved last night. I am a big fan of Will and Twitch so when they do well I just get goosebumps. Comfort... if she had not lucked out with hip hop routine after hip hop routine she would have been gone long ago. Mark is quirky and neat but I am done with him. So, those two can go.
Katee- I can't believe she almost didn't make the show- she ROCKS. I did not think Courtney was as strong as the judges thought she was on the Samba number... I remember thinking to myself that Will was kicking her butt on that. Chelsie is great but she doesn't shine for me like the other two girls.
11Last night was so good it hurt. I did not enjoy Will in the samba as much as everyone else seemed to I mean those samba rolls were horrific, but I loved his solo because for once it looked like he had a personality and he was having fun. I have not been Wills biggest fan but he is definitely a good dancer. Twitch finally went for it last night and while he has always been my favorite (because he just reminds me so much of my little brother and his dancing style) he totally proved himself technically I think in both dances. And did anybody else catch that smokin hot smooch between him and Katee? Joshua and Chelsie didn't seem to like each other no matter how much they kept saying they were joking but they put it all aside on the dance floor. And again I say Comfort better be going home tonight or something is really up with those phone lines. After Comfort leaves I don't really want anyone to get cut. Can't there just be 6 winners this year?
12Thanks fireyelectra! Curlywhirl, I agree w/ the kiss!! ewww. hahaha! I guess they just went all out w/ it since they are old friends.
13Also I would like to say, Mia Michaels Mia Michaels Mia Michaels. She is PHENOMENAL. Also I miss Shane Sparks routines.
14And another thing, it is really surprising to me that out of the thousands of people who try out, every season there seems to be people who are either related (Benji and Heidi, Travis and Danny, Benji and Lacey) or know each other well (Katee and Twitch, Comfort and Joshua) in the top ten!!
15Oh man last night was gooood. Twitch and Katee's first dance was awesome and then I was definitely with the judges for Will and Courtney's contemporary...so very dramatic. I think Comfort and Mark are going home tonight (sorry Mark
), but after that I think they all deserve to win.
16Comfort and Mark will probably be gone tonight. Comfort should have been gone awhile ago. I love Mark, but out of the remaining guys he is next to go. I actually missed Katee andd Twitch in their first number last night so I just watched it on youtube and wow! LOVED it!!! I really enjoyed their 2nd number too and Twitch's solo...always! Katee, don't like her solos too much. I think Will was great, as usual. Chelsie and Joshua have good chemistry and I liked their Argentine Tango, but their disco was so so. All in all, it was a good night though.
17I loved last night! Almost all of the dances were amazing! yea!
18I think Comfort and Mark are going home. I'm sad about Mark, he's so fun and quirky, not so sad about Comfort. She's great in hiphop, but not in anything else. Its time for her to go.
Oh, and I absolutely LOVED Twitch and Katee!
I agree with you guys, Mark will probably go home tonight, which makes me sad because I LOOOOVE him... but he isn't the strongest of the guys left. If Comfort doesn't go home I'll be pretty surprised. And annoyed!
Also agree that the judging seemed biased- although the disco number was challenging technically, I thought it came across as somewhat clunky. I thought Will's hips on the samba were lacking, but the judges failed to mention it. (I think- I could be wrong.) And calling Mark and Comfort's fox trot "amateurish" was extremely harsh, undeservedly so. Granted it was one of, if not the, weakest routines last night, but that's more because most of the others were so outstanding. The criticism seemed disproportionately brutal.
19I too watched Twitch and Katee's dance at least 3 times last night. I absolutely loved it and the song selection was perfect. Love Duffy! Twitch fell out of my graces a little last week but he was back last night and I am in love, love, love again.
20I thought the disco felt clunky too, but I think it got a bit too crazy with all the lifts - too many to fit in much dancing around it, and Joshua in particular must have been absolutely exhausted! But I loved their argentine tango. Definitely loved Twitch and Katie, especially the contemporary. Its got to be Mark and Comfort to go (snif - I love Mark! Though my boyfriend says he looks like a Wiggle - and he does!), then it gets REALLY tough! Unfortunately, I think I'll miss the final because I'll be travelling. NOooooooooo!
21Comfort & Mark are definitely going home tonight.
22I love Mark, so I don't want him to go, but I'm basically counting down the minutes he has left. haha.
Last night was really enjoyable,
although I don't think Josh & Chelsie's disco was anything fantastic.
Everyone was very entertaining last night.
So sad that I have to say goodbye to Mark this week... unfortunately he just doesn't hold a candle to Will, Joshua and Twitch...
Katee hanging on the door... BEST.MOMENT.EVA
23I don't want to spoil it for anyone who tivoed it but I am in shock.
24WOW... America got it wrong this week... Too bad I'm Canadian and don't get to vote
25i am so shocked about the guy who went home
26I'm floored by the guy going home tonight! I thought either he or Katee would win.
27I want to punch America in the face.
28uh oh. I haven't watched it yet. I wonder if it is Will? If it wasn't Mark, then it is a shame!
29I am still so sad over last night's vote!!!! He was THE BEST dancer they have had in the past few seasons. All I have to say is, Katee better win now!
30Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.