
It's really starting to feel like crunch time on American Idol. The six final contestants (remember way back when we still had 24?) did their best Broadway impressions on Tuesday, belting the show tunes of Andrew Lloyd Webber. Which contestant will be only a "Memory" after tonight? Make your choice below!
Photo courtesy of Fox

















L'Autre Chose
Hanii Y
theOutnet
It's either going to be Brooke or Jason, but I am thinking Jason has more fans than Brooke.
1Definitely Brooke.
2Bye, bye, Brooke!
3Jason was awful!!!!!!!!
4Brooke is really sucking lately.
5I voted for Jason, who really sucked but it's between him and Brooke because she's not getting any better..
6I feel really sorry for Brooke but it has to be her. She keeps on going downhill
7Brooke and Jason are DEF in the bottom 3. I can't believe Jason tried Memory, that's a BIG song and he just doesn't have the voice for it. Last night was a good night for Syesha (Who I normally don't like) and David A (who I also am not a HUGE fan). I think they're more on this level then on pop start level. Both should probably look into broadway tpye stuff. I did love Carly's Jesus Christ Super Star and David C was Grrrrreat too. Good song choice man. I love Phantom so was glad to see he didn't butcher it.
8Brooke needs to go home. While I really didn't like Jason last night, I usually Do like him and I totally like him better than Brooke. She always looks like she's pouting and going to cry. it's annoying
Jason is awesome but I think he's just ot star material. Would do nice as an indie singer though.
9At this point I don't care much which smurf goes. I think Brooke will be the next one though.
10Brooke or Jason, definitely. But I feel Brooke has been consistently rather poor or mediocre these few weeks, and she is less talented than Jason. So Brooke should go.
11Jason should go, but Brooke probably will go.
12Brooke should go. I liked her but I think the nerves have gotten to her big time. I know Jason wasn't that great either, but in his defense could you really see him singing *any* ALW song in his style? Just sayin'. I think any theatrical song he'd pick would have been slammed.
13em1282, granted that the Idol contestants only get 24 songs to choose from each week, I think Castro could have chosen a better one. He might have actually done really well if he had chosen "Close Every Door" from Joseph & the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat, or "Another Suitcase, Another Hall" from Evita. Those songs both have slower tempos, but they aren't really meant for that big of a voice. His whispery-stoner style would have worked really well for "Another Suitcase."
14Also, Brooke should have done "Only He" from Starlight Express. Her voice is much better suited to the range of that song than the incredibly low range of "You Must Love Me." Brooke's got a chest voice, true, but that doesn't mean she has a low range. If "One Rock and Roll Too Many" was a choice for them, "Only He" had to have been one.
15I would love for Syesha to go home,but I think it's between Brooke or Jason.
16I think Brooke is great but I think the last two challenges have really screwed her over. Mariah and Weber songs are made for big voices and that's just not Brooke. I am really mad at her because she is my favorite and she needed a great night. She just didn't pull through. I hope Castro goes, but I"m prepared to say goodbye to Brookie
17Why does everyone love David A? He is so boring!
18I think Brooke will go home. I like Jason, i think he is adorable, he didn't do that well last night but he usually does.
When i was listening to the radio on my way to work this morning the two dj's were arguing over if Jason was stoned or not last night. It was pretty funny!
19See ya Brooke....she needs to go...also, I really don't like Jason...it is like watching water boil when he sings...kinda the saem with David A. - he needs to stop being so boring. David Cook for the win!!! I l-o-v-e him and I loved how he pulled of that song...
20Brooke... Just Go!
21I love David A because he's like a little newborn puppy. How can anyone NOT like him? Plus he has a lovely voice.
And I love David Cook because he's just so bloody sexy (and talented).
22Tired of Brooke a long time ago. Too big for her.
23I think that Brooke relied on KLC and Ramiele or atleast they made her feel secure cause since they left, I feel like she seems so terribly nervous
24I can't believe I haven't watched a single episode of Idol this season.
25if brooke doesn't go home tonight i will stop watching...ok, i lied, nothing can keep me from tuning in to watch my beloved David Cook. But really, Brooke is boring as is Little David, I don't get the hype surrounding that one. But whatever.
26Brooke. As much as I love her, last night was by far her worst performance.
27Jason is the one going home I wouldn't vote someone off if they became unprepared, I least Simon was more understanding to Brooke then Paula was, I can nobody's perfect but you voted someone off because they weren't ready or forgot the Words that happen too David Archuleta like 6 weeks ago I didn't panicked then why should I now.
28Besides David Cook, Syesha and Carly have made Me Believed last Night By The Way they'll be back Next week.
Brooke should be going home. Each week is getting rougher and rougher. I love Jason, maybe because he reminds me of the guys I play with and his voice reminds me a bit of my husband's. It wasn;t Jason's best week, but it was one off night, as opposed to Brooke's having several. I love Brooke, but it's time for her to leave. Jason can go next week if he has another off performance. I absolutely would vote someone off for starting and stopping because of lost lyrics. At that level, it's just not cool. It was bad enough when she stopped udring "Every Breath You Take" because of pitch issues. She was unprepared twice, different reasons, but unprepared nonetheless.
29Brooke, unfortunately. I really like everyone left except Syesha and maybe Carly but they both did well last night.
30for some crazy reason Brooke was safe... what the heck america. at least Jason is safe
31Brooke got sympathy votes. She shoulda been the one to leave, not Carly. BOGUS!!
32Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.