Ever wonder what a movie or TV show would be like if you could be the casting director? Well, every Wednesday on BuzzSugar, I'll be posting a Recast challenge, where I'll ask you to recast a classic TV show or movie for these modern times.
This week's challenge: the irresistible Southern chick-flick, Steel Magnolias. I'll be the first to admit that this movie was very well cast the first time around — with the exception, in my opinion, of Julia Roberts. But it's been almost 20 years since Steel Magnolias came out, so who could fill these great female roles today? Leave your entry us in the comment section below, and I'll pick one winner to feature next Tuesday, Jan. 16, complete with a "new" cast photo.
Characters to recast:
M'Lynn (Sally Field)
Truvy (Dolly Parton)
Ouiser (Shirley MacLaine)
Annelle (Darryl Hannah)
Clairee (Olympia Dukakis)
Shelby (Julia Roberts)

















Julia Cocco'
Saint Tropez
Manoush
Wow, this was hard. This movie is so perfectly cast already. I went back and forth on these, but here is a fun cast:
M'Lynn - Kyra Sedgwick
1Truvy - Regina King
Ouiser - Doris Roberts
Annelle - Rachel McAdams
Clairee - Gena Rowlands
Shelby - Kate Bosworth
i wouldnt dare to attempt to recast this!
2Shelby- Reese Witherspoon (Can be caring and/or scared just like Shelby)
M'Lynn- Stockard Channing (she is so confident just like M'Lynn)
Annelee- Liv Tyler (Her soft spoken self would shine through in this role!)
Truvy- Ashley Judd (In mind would be PERFECT in this role!)
Ouiser- Carrie Fischer
Clairee- Cathrine O'Hara
I think these last two actress' would play off each other great!
This cast would be AMAZING! to see together!
3Liv Tyler was one of my choices for Anelle too! I was going back and forth on that one. I like Reese as Shelby too, good call.
4Thanks. The only toss up I had on there was Reese. I think she can do it though, we know she has the twang but I don't know if she can be "scared." It doesn't seem like the right word, well you know probably.
5But thanks:D
Wow good job. I thought of some, but I haven't been able to put them all together. Three's Company was hard enough for me, lol.
------------------------------------------------------
6Imagination is more important than knowledge. Knowledge is limited. Albert Einstein
Annelle Dupuy Desoto (Daryl Hannah) – Reese Witherspoon
7M'Lynn Eatenton (Sally Field) – Goldie Hawn
Shelby Eatenton Latcherie (Julia Roberts) – Kate Hudson
Truvy Jones (Dolly Parton) - Jennifer Coolidge
Ouiser Boudreaux (Shirley MacLaine) - Bette Midler
Clairee Belcher (Olympia Dukakis) - Meryl Streep
Ah, one of the only chick flicks I actually like!
My two oldest laides (Ouiser & Clairee) aren't as old as the originals, though.
M'Lynn - Julianne Moore
8Truvy - Jennifer Coolidge
Ouiser - Annette Bening
Annelle - Amy Adams
Clairee - Frances McDormand
Shelby - Anne Hathaway
M'Lynn - Michelle Pfeiffer
9Shelby - Clare Danes
Truvy - Sharon Stone
Annelle - Rachel McAdams
Ouiser - Bette Midler
Clairee - Meryl Streep
M'Lynn-Joan Allen
10Clarie-Marcia Gay Harden
Ouiser-Diane Wiest
Truvy-Reba McIntyre
Annelle-Christina Ricci
Shelby-Jennifer Garner
**StellaStar**
M'Lynn (Joan Allen)
11Truvy (Bette Midler)
Ouiser (Meryl Streep)
Annelle (Parker Posey)
Clairee (Annette Benning)
Shelby (Brittney Murphy)
i cant do this, its my all time favorite movie
12i know he thinks you're fine and stuff but does he know how to wind you up?
Same here, flutterpie!
Although I like the suggestions for Reese as Shelby, Liv as Anelle and Goldie as M'Lynn!
13Here are mine!:
M'Lynn: Annette Benning
Truvy: Reba McIntyre
Ouiser: Bea Anderson
Annelle: American Ferrera
Clairee: Meryl Streep
Shelby: Michelle Trachtenburg
I'm all in.
14To my opinion this is another movie that can't be re-cast... In this movie everyone is so into their own rolls that if any producer would try to re-make this movie with a different cast it WOULD NOT BE THE SAME...
15Okay, I have mixed feelings about even attempting to do this, especially since this movie was filmed in my home state and we feel partial ownership over it, but, here it goes anyway:
M'Lynn: Felicity Huffman
16Truvy: Kyra Segwick
Ouiser: Susan Sarandon
Annelle: Kimberly Williams
Clairee: Meryl Streep
Shelby: Amy Adams
Some of these ideas are great... But I couldn't possiblity re-cast one of my favorite (if not FAVORITE)movie...
17This is one of my favorites! It will be hard to beat, I think....
18M'Lynn:Diane Lane
Truvy:Kim Basinger
Shelby: Hillary Swank
Annelle:Jamie King
Clairee:Helen Mirren
Ouiser:Jane Fonda
Just for Fun:
Jackson:Jake Gyllenhaal
Drum:George Clooney
M'Lynn (Sally Field) - Blythe Danner
19Truvy (Dolly Parton) - Dolly Parton (she looks about the same age)
Ouiser (Shirley MacLaine) - Elaine Stritch
Annelle (Darryl Hannah) - Julianne Moore
Clairee (Olympia Dukakis) - Meryl Streep
Shelby (Julia Roberts) - Sarah Jessica Parker...or the Lohan.
M'Lynn - Cybill Shepherd
20Truvy - Ashley Judd
Ouiser - Bette Midler
Annelle - Andie MacDowell
Clairee - Dixie Carter
Shelby - Reese Witherspoon
M'Lynn (Sally Field) - Meryl Streep
21Truvy (Dolly Parton) - Goldie Hawn
Ouiser (Shirley MacLaine) - Dixie Carter
Annelle (Darryl Hannah) - Jennifer Garner
Clairee (Olympia Dukakis) - Andie McDowell
Shelby (Julia Roberts)- Reese Witherspoon
M'Lynn - Susan Sarandon
22Truvy - Jean Smart
Ouiser - Annette Benning
Annelle - Liv Tyler
Clairee - Meryl Streep
Shelby - Jennifer Garner
One of my favorite movies!
M'Lynn (Sally Field)- Michelle Pfeiffer
23Truvy (Dolly Parton) - Ashley Judd
Ouiser (Shirley Maclaine) - Holly Hunter
Annelle (Darryl Hannah) - Claire Danes
Clairee (Olympia Dukakis) - Meryl Streep
Shelby (Julia Roberts) - Rachel McAdams
Oops...change my Meryl Streep entry for the role of Clairee to Blythe Danner. Much better fit.
New entry:
M'Lynn - Michelle Pfeiffer
24Truvy - Ashley Judd
Ouiser - Holly Hunter
Annelle - Claire Danes
Clairee - Blythe Danner
Shelby - Rachel MacAdams
M'Lynn Annette Bennings or Michelle Phiffer
Ouiser Gina Rowlands or Rolands (not sure how you spell that)
Annelle Dru Barrymore
Shelby Mandy Moore
Truvy Reba McIntyre
Clairee Ellen Burstyn
Style Before Comfort!
25M'Lynn -- Holly Hunter
26Truvy -- Hillary Swank
Ouise -- Doris Roberts (the mom from Everybody Loves Raymond)
Annelle -- Drew Barrymore
Clairee -- Diane Keaton
Shelby -- Reese Witherspoon
I don't think you could really improve on the original, but here are my picks:
M'Lynn--Jean Smart
Shelby--Rachel McAdams
Truvy--Ashley Judd
Oiser--Lily Tomlin
Clairee--Stockard Channing
Annelle--Michelle Williams
(btw, Ashley Judd as Truvy instantly came to mind when I saw the challenge...funny how many others also can totally see her in that role, as she is really different from Dolly!)
27That would be hard to do.
28Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.